I know there are many threads about both but this thread is specifically about my theory and the comparison of the two technologies.
OK. Many have pointed out that Asgard beaming technology is far superior to that of the ancients rings and wonder why the ancients were so far behind. I have several points that i think prove that the rings were far more efficient compared to that of the Asgard beaming technology.
1.) This isn't really a point but the Ancients have beaming technology. As demonstrated in Avalon and Camelot.
2.) Beams can be stopped with a jamming device. Obviously shields can stop both the rings and beams, but as demonstrated in several episodes rings can go through a heck of a lot of interference.(Black Holes!) The Wraith stopped the Asgard beams but the much more powerful Ori could not stop the ringing in of Daniel Jackson. Rings can go through a heck of a lot more interference.
3.) Power: Beaming Technology could be taken out lets say if a ships power generation capabilities are destroyed, but rings are an independent system that can be activated from the sending and receiving side. This provides a huge tactical advantage compared to beaming. If a 304 was low on power and a nearby ship and/or planet had rings they could ring out with relative ease.
In conclusion the rings may be technologically inferior but they work better in more situations. The Ancients weren't stupid people they obviously knew that they worked better. I look as the drones as another example of this. Some energy based weapons may be more powerful than drones ,but ancients preferred them because of their different capabilities as projectiles and energy based weapons.
Thor would be mad i just bashed the Asgard but i still love those guys.
OK. Many have pointed out that Asgard beaming technology is far superior to that of the ancients rings and wonder why the ancients were so far behind. I have several points that i think prove that the rings were far more efficient compared to that of the Asgard beaming technology.
1.) This isn't really a point but the Ancients have beaming technology. As demonstrated in Avalon and Camelot.
2.) Beams can be stopped with a jamming device. Obviously shields can stop both the rings and beams, but as demonstrated in several episodes rings can go through a heck of a lot of interference.(Black Holes!) The Wraith stopped the Asgard beams but the much more powerful Ori could not stop the ringing in of Daniel Jackson. Rings can go through a heck of a lot more interference.
3.) Power: Beaming Technology could be taken out lets say if a ships power generation capabilities are destroyed, but rings are an independent system that can be activated from the sending and receiving side. This provides a huge tactical advantage compared to beaming. If a 304 was low on power and a nearby ship and/or planet had rings they could ring out with relative ease.
In conclusion the rings may be technologically inferior but they work better in more situations. The Ancients weren't stupid people they obviously knew that they worked better. I look as the drones as another example of this. Some energy based weapons may be more powerful than drones ,but ancients preferred them because of their different capabilities as projectiles and energy based weapons.
Thor would be mad i just bashed the Asgard but i still love those guys.
Comment