best ep so far

[nova]

my opinion is, it is, i thought this was awesome, the old mckay/miller eps are great

and wot shep did suprised me alot (but the guy did deserve to be eat by a wraith)

[The_Carpenter]

my opinion is, it is, i thought this was awesome, the old mckay/miller eps are great

and wot shep did suprised me alot (but the guy did deserve to be eat by a wraith)

Wouldn't say its the best one so far, but its defiantly turned out to be a love it or hate it deal which is in no small part due to Sheps actions at the end which has got loads of people debating the ins and outs of it all which can only be a good thing.

[Jumper_One]

Wouldn't say its the best one so far, but its defiantly turned out to be a love it or hate it deal which is in no small part due to Sheps actions at the end which has got loads of people debating the ins and outs of it all which can only be a good thing.

I agree

but nova why didn't you post this in the general discussion thread?

[jelgate]

The Seer was better than Miller's Crossing. That said this was a entertaining episode and made me think.?*

[nova]

sorry, ill remember that for next time

ps. its always good to see mckay being told wot to do

[Phenix]

my opinion is, it is, i thought this was awesome, the old mckay/miller eps are great

and wot shep did suprised me alot (but the guy did deserve to be eat by a wraith)

I'm not a fan of McKay centric episodes. He irritates me. The first 30 minutes were very very predictable but the last 30 made up for it. It was a good episode but I don't think it was the best one yet.

[g.o.d]

Lifeline was better...better than the average

[txTart]

I totally agree with Nova. So far, my favorite episode of the series, though Doppelganger, Echoes and Tao of McKay are in a tie for second.

[blue-skyz]

Not my favorite episode ever. But the Sheppard scenes and the Sheppard and McKay scenes at the end will probably turn out to be my favorite scenes ever.

I can't wait to see what else the season holds in store.