How about a episode called "The Battle"

[cjp240573]

What with all the debate regarding the Asguard, Orii & Wrath. Would it be good for SG1 to have a few cheaper episodes and then go for a big "The Battle" episode where the Asguard & Orii just kick each other buts but then to make things worse 5 hive ships arrive. That way we would know who is the strongest of them all, well of the Orii and Asguard.

Go, go do it.
Cliff

[LeeWilliamHutchison]

Sounds like a mans masterbation fantasy

[The Engineer]

No, that would be a bad and an inimaginative episde.
And what if the Borgs arrive along with the Scarran and all the villains we know and engage in a battle, "The Battle".
It's like Alien vs. Predator (the movie). Bleahhhh!!!

[lionel_pendergast_rocks]

Yeah, there's no reason for hive ships to enter a battle like that, in THIS galaxy, or even in the Asgard or Ori galaxie.

[thegatebuilders]

how abaout the atlantis team lead the wraith into the Ori galaxy in the hope of finding earth. that would be cool, two super villians in the battle for survival. Would the Ori allow the Wraith to feed on their followers, now that would be an episode worthy of the title

[The Ori]

What would be good is if the Wraith that are trying to go to our Galaxy in the end of season 2 end up coming out of hperspace to confront the wraith ships oh sicko.

[IcyNeko]

What with all the debate regarding the Asguard, Orii & Wrath. Would it be good for SG1 to have a few cheaper episodes and then go for a big "The Battle" episode where the Asguard & Orii just kick each other buts but then to make things worse 5 hive ships arrive. That way we would know who is the strongest of them all, well of the Orii and Asguard.

Go, go do it.
Cliff

oh hae d00d u know wat would be kewl if the writers made an episode where the enterprise (kirk) and the enterprise (picard) and the battlestar galactica and the battlestar pegasus and a cylon base star and the yamato and the ori and the asgard and the tollan and the goa'uld and martin's race and a star destroyer and a death star and a mon calamari star cruiser and the last star fighter and space ball one all appeared in your living room and started shooting each other it would be the kewlestststertrerst thing evar and we could find out who was teh awesomest!!!11!!eleven.

Seriously, the writers should make this episode



when they're ready to let drooling fanboys of science fiction ruin the genre forever.

[jenks]

Asgard, Ori & Wraith.

[NKD]

when they're ready to let drooling fanboys of science fiction ruin the genre forever.

"Drooling fanboys of science fiction" describes this forum pretty well. I'm a huge fan of the Stargate franchise and came here looking for some good discussion about the direction the show, what storylines are focused on, and so forth.

Unfortunately, here is what I have found:

1) People making softcore porn fantasies about the characters. (This isnt a soap, people. They are never going to make in depth on-screen romances between leads in 'Stargate'.)

2) "Technology/Effects Kiddies" These people seem to be obsessed with the fictional technology and fictional weaponry that is used in the show. They also tend to get upset when the fictional technology isn't fully explained or lacks continuity. They often make poorly constructed, poorly spelled threads saying things like "omg tehy ned more sihps and mor batle! mor kewll tehcnolgoly".

3) Wild speculation about non-existent storylines. Essentially people pitching terrible, terrible story ideas on the boards. One recent example: "waht if ronon si a RAITH becoz he has teh dreads and is strnog n stuf". While I am not a big fan of "fan fiction", I think people should write some fan fiction instead of making threads about it.


At this point, 'Stargate' should focus on quality over quantity. Good science fiction, and good 'Stargate', doesn't mean a bunch of new technotoys every week, or 90% of the shows taking place onboard some ship, or even a bunch of huge space battles.

[Chutzpah]

At this point, 'Stargate' should focus on quality over quantity. Good science fiction, and good 'Stargate', doesn't mean a bunch of new technotoys every week, or 90% of the shows taking place onboard some ship, or even a bunch of huge space battles.

That doesn't leave much room for new episode ideas. They trapped themselves a little in season 9 with Earth having a few ships able to do battle and jet around the galaxy quickly. Hopefully the new enemy will destroy the majority of them.

Spoiler:

(After the season 9 Camelot episode i think we only have 1 ship left)

Then we can go back to the orginal infiltrate and sabotage against extrodinary odds type of story lines.

[IcyNeko]

Well put, NKD. While I tend to edge on #2, I still have enough control to not turn myself into a drooling mess over the technology.

Still, storylines, storylines, storylines! This cannot be emphasized enough! Not a "OMG let's bring everyone in the 'verse here and shoot at each other until we know who's teh coolest who's with me let's go guys omgimsocool". But something where we learn a little more about each character.

[llama]

Spoiler:

well technically earth has 2 ships coz they have the Daedalus and the Oddysey but the Daedalus is in stargate atlantis and the Oddysey is in sg-1, coz the korolev exploded and died by the ori

[Cunha00]

Spoiler:

well technically earth has 2 ships coz they have the Daedalus and the Oddysey but the Daedalus is in stargate atlantis and the Oddysey is in sg-1, coz the korolev exploded and died by the ori

Spoiler:

if i remenber, it was the rusian ship that was destroied not the odissey

[IcyNeko]

That's what he said, I think.

[GhostPoet]

After the battle a giant race of marshmellow beings attack the survivors.