Finished SGU: So, is that it?

[Wulfmann]

Seriously (Eric Cartman accent)

While in a small way the way it ended with the obvious intent to pick up on how Elli saved himself and they started anew in another galaxy it also allowed a decent end if it did not have a season three so while I am disappointed at no 3 it could have been worse.

Imagine if it ended after season one in the middle of the takeover attempt, much much worse.

However, with this in limbo what possibility will there be a wrap up, A "Peace Keeper Wars" "Ark of Truth and Continuum" movie idea???

Anyone? Anyone?

Bueller?

Wulfmann

[SoulReaver]

yup

[Ser Scot A Ellison]

Hell,

I'd be satisfied with a novel to finish out the story. It was going somewhere very interesting and it sucks that I'll never get to see it.

[hedwig]

Seriously (Eric Cartman accent)

While in a small way the way it ended with the obvious intent to pick up on how Elli saved himself and they started anew in another galaxy it also allowed a decent end if it did not have a season three so while I am disappointed at no 3 it could have been worse.

Imagine if it ended after season one in the middle of the takeover attempt, much much worse.

However, with this in limbo what possibility will there be a wrap up, A "Peace Keeper Wars" "Ark of Truth and Continuum" movie idea???

Anyone? Anyone?

Bueller?

Wulfmann

Sadly ... highly unlikely.

[rushy]

Forget novels, we need a third season(personally I'd like ten more) of SGU to wrap it up.

[timstro59]

I know it's hard to accept, but life goes on.

[Snowman37]

However, with this in limbo what possibility will there be a wrap up, A "Peace Keeper Wars" "Ark of Truth and Continuum" movie idea???

No. A pitch was proposed to MGM, but the studio ultimately cancelled the entire franchise. This was a consequence of bankruptcy. Everything SG was sold or auctioned off. This includes everything from SGU. All of the producers, writers, actors, and everyone else were let go. All proposed scripts and pitches were shelved indefinitely. There will be no wrap up movie. It's simply over.

It stinks, but so did the cliffhanger finales for Surface and Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles. There's also Jericho which opened up a huge story at the end of the final episode. No cliffhanger, but we were introduced to this huge, national story that ultimately went untold.

[python490]

Yeah unless there is a re-boot of some sort. The franchise is pretty much on hold. Sad but true.

[Snowman37]

I think he was asking about SGU, specifically. A reboot would likely ignore SGU entirely. Would a rebooted SG even have stargates with nine chevrons? What if they only have eight? Bye-bye, SGU.

[rushy]

The entire franchise is over, no reboot's gonna happen unless Devlin does it. Or a fan film like ST: Of Gods and Men(better than the 09 movie Abrams made).

[KEK]

They could easily do a series reboot. I doubt it would be any time soon though. Then again, is there any real indication that Syfy (or anyone else) don't want more Stargate? It seems to be more a case of the existing producers calling it quits, and the people and MGM/Spyglass being in no rush to push something through.

[Snowman37]

The entire franchise is over, no reboot's gonna happen unless Devlin does it.

I agree, the franchise is pretty much over. Who says a reboot is the only way? Just because it's popular, that does not mean it is the only means for SG to return. Are we forgetting the 18-year-gap between Star Trek and The Next Generation? Yes, there were a few movies, but ST had been off the air for nearly two decades. It returned with a spin-off, not as a reboot. As for Devlin, he's not interested in rebooting the franchise. Rather, he's interested in producing a sequel to the original movie.

Or a fan film like ST: Of Gods and Men(better than the 09 movie Abrams made).

Please, no fan films, yikes!

They could easily do a series reboot. I doubt it would be any time soon though. Then again, is there any real indication that Syfy (or anyone else) don't want more Stargate? It seems to be more a case of the existing producers calling it quits, and the people and MGM/Spyglass being in no rush to push something through.

Who says the producers called it quits? Brad Wright tried hard to pitch various SG movie concepts to MGM. The studio is the one who called it quits. Don't forget the American economy. Yeah, SG was made in Canada, but the studio who owns and funded it is based in the USA. With our economy in the toilet, no television studio is going to want to fund an expensive show like Stargate or Star Trek. Factoring in the economy, the high expense to produce such a show, and the loss of interest in space travel among the American people; that means no more space-based science-fiction on TV. Sorry, folks. If you want new space fiction, you're going to have to look toward the movies and literature.

[KEK]

Who says the producers called it quits? Brad Wright tried hard to pitch various SG movie concepts to MGM. The studio is the one who called it quits. Don't forget the American economy. Yeah, SG was made in Canada, but the studio who owns and funded it is based in the USA. With our economy in the toilet, no television studio is going to want to fund an expensive show like Stargate or Star Trek. Factoring in the economy, the high expense to produce such a show, and the loss of interest in space travel among the American people; that means no more space-based science-fiction on TV. Sorry, folks. If you want new space fiction, you're going to have to look toward the movies and literature.

Which were all continuations of their established lore. They weren't new series or new stories, just continuations or completions of the old ones. They said all along they would not be interested in making another series, and if SG-1/SGA/SGU completely ended then so would their involvement in Stargate. I don't think the economy is a valid reason, the commissioning of high budget genre shows has not stopped or slowed, quite the contrary if anything. It certainly could be true that no networks are interested in Stargate any more, I was just saying that I don't think we have any concrete indication of that.

[Snowman37]

Which were all continuations of their established lore. They weren't new series or new stories, just continuations or completions of the old ones.

I was not disputing that.

I don't think the economy is a valid reason, the commissioning of high budget genre shows has not stopped or slowed, quite the contrary if anything. It certainly could be true that no networks are interested in Stargate any more, I was just saying that I don't think we have any concrete indication of that.

Perhaps, but space based science-fiction television programming requires new costumes, props, sets, and so on. Alternatively, most TV shows today can use existing costumes, props, and sets. That's why the space-based TV shows are gone for now.

[KEK]

Perhaps, but space based science-fiction television programming requires new costumes, props, sets, and so on. Alternatively, most TV shows today can use existing costumes, props, and sets. That's why the space-based TV shows are gone for now.

Fantasy shows need new costumes sets, sets and props too. Most of which cost more than Stargate did. If any networks were to be effected by the economy most, it would be premium ones like HBO who spend insane amounts and shoot all over the world, yet look at GoT. Seriously, the TV landscape really hasn't been effected that much. If space operas aren't commercially viable, then it'll be down to lack of interest more than anything. I don't believe either is the case however, but I do suspect that's the way the network execs see it.

[rushy]

I agree, the franchise is pretty much over. Who says a reboot is the only way? Just because it's popular, that does not mean it is the only means for SG to return. Are we forgetting the 18-year-gap between Star Trek and The Next Generation? Yes, there were a few movies, but ST had been off the air for nearly two decades. It returned with a spin-off, not as a reboot. As for Devlin, he's not interested in rebooting the franchise. Rather, he's interested in producing a sequel to the original movie.

The sequel was actually what I thought(wrong words). I'd love to see it, but I doubt that the original actors(maybe except Skaara or O'Neil) would return.

Please, no fan films, yikes!

Trust me. I know exactly what you're thinking but Star Trek: Of Gods and Men isn't a "fan" fan film considering that it was directed by Tim Russ(Tuvok) and the main protagonists were Chekov, Uhura and Harriman, all played by original actors. Also, the actors for Harry Kim, Neelix and Soval were also present with different characters. Trust me, it wasn't a fan film, it was totally epic.
The story: An old Charlie Evans comes back from Thasian space and before the protagonists can stop him, he uses the Guardian of Forever to prevent Kirk's birth. As a result, a mirror universe-like reality is created where Uhura and Tuvok live on Vulcan, Harriman is a murderer in charge of the GSS Conqueror, Chekov's a freedom fighter and the Galactic Power is ruled by Kirot Prime who once was a man named Gary Mitchell.

Now I'd see a Stargate film that looks like that any day.

[rushy]

Maybe create an interesting version of Infinity with a totally different plot.

[KEK]

I think the basic premise of Infinity is the only thing about it that isn't dire.

[Mnikolic]

Well, the best thing that each of us can do is everyone writing the ending for themselves if unable to let go. I'm sure by re-watching the show, make plot, story and character notes, that is not impossible. The only rule is not to go public with it at anytime anywhere.

Maybe when this d*** crisis is over, we'll see more Stargate. It's MGM's call. Once they'll want more Stargate, we'll get new Stargate. Or maybe even movies to finish off Atlantis and Universe stories. Either that or new ones.

As far as it goes for me, I already have an ending made up in my head. Actually, I have thought of how the entire SGU season 3, 4 and 5 + Atlantis AND SG-1 movie(s) could go and what they'd be about.

[rushy]

Well, the best thing that each of us can do is everyone writing the ending for themselves if unable to let go. I'm sure by re-watching the show, make plot, story and character notes, that is not impossible. The only rule is not to go public with it at anytime anywhere.

Maybe when this d*** crisis is over, we'll see more Stargate. It's MGM's call. Once they'll want more Stargate, we'll get new Stargate. Or maybe even movies to finish off Atlantis and Universe stories. Either that or new ones.

As far as it goes for me, I already have an ending made up in my head. Actually, I have thought of how the entire SGU season 3, 4 and 5 + Atlantis AND SG-1 movie(s) could go and what they'd be about.

If it's not too much to ask, please share your version of the ending(better than nothing).