SGA FAN / New to Forum / Ideas !!

[Kenton-Atlantis]

Hey everyone,

I just wanted to talk about what i think was the greatest series of the Stargate. Im so dissapointed that it was cut short for SGU. i dont understand there was so much more material. now that there on Earth the show coulda contiuned 2 more seasons. talking about how Tayla and Ronan get used to living there full time. i always enjoyed when Ronan Dex would accompany Col. Sheppard to earth. like when John's father dies and when Mckay and his sister are kidnapped, I like when they make Ronan Change his close and he says " Doesent matter what you dress me in ill still stand out". I was really dissapointed that Amanda tapping never stayed on the SGA longer then a season. I dont like Wolsey never did like his part on the show. But im really exited for the movies. I wanna no whats going on with them and if anyone has any opinions on how they could have wrote scripts for new seasons. I own all the seasons but 5 and still waiting for it to be delivered i always watch them again. Thanks Everyone !!

Kenton McGann
Canada -

[fumblesmcstupid]

Howdy and welcome.

I really didn't like Woolsey to start off on SG-1...I don't think you were supposed to though.

I did like him on Atlantis...weird HUH?.

Rodney and John are my favorites. I like Teyla & Ronon too.

I am sad on one hand that Atlantis is over. I'm glad on another hand too. I really didn't like the way the show was headed.

[Kenton-Atlantis]

I here ya man. Yeah i used to watch Ricardo when he was on Star Trek Voyager never liked him on that either just carried on. I just bought 5th season today about to watch it. I no a bit but not all am i in for a good Season??

[fumblesmcstupid]

*uh......weeellll..hmmmm....*laughs*.......I am one of the BIGGEST critics of season 5.

You should go through all the episodes and be your own judge.

As for me..

I only really liked 3 episodes all the way through (Search & Rescue, Daedulus Variations and Prodigal.

All the rest were ruined (for me) by a character I hate (Keller), a relationship that just gives me nightmares (Rodney/Keller) and character assassinations on pretty much the main characters.

I haven't bought the 5th season..and I won't.

[Kenton-Atlantis]

Well i did finish the season and i liked about 5 episodes all the ones u said but i also enjoyed VEGAS and The Queen i thought they were great. Im actually glad i bought it but i here ya everyone has there own opinion. I really wish they woulda done one more season. But i heard that Rodney McKay will be on SGU cool eh. I also thought that Rodney and Keller was kinda cute in a way i was a supporter. Like when McKay tells Ronon " Let the best man Win "

[fumblesmcstupid]

I dislike Keller so *shrug*

I Love Rodney.

I won't touch the Rodney/Keller pairing conversation with a 10 foot pole.

*Shudders*

[Kenton-Atlantis]

lol yeah i was kinda hoping RONON would get her but hey McKay is the man we can agree with that!!!

[Falcon Horus]

lol yeah i was kinda hoping RONON would get her but hey McKay is the man we can agree with that!!!

Nope, we can't...

[Kenton-Atlantis]

LOL ohh come on !

[Falcon Horus]

LOL ohh come on !

I don't dislike Rodney... I just would have liked to have seen less of him. A lot less.

Besides I preferred Katie/Rodney over Keller/Rodney.

[Kenton-Atlantis]

i agree 100% the Katie/ Rodney was a much better set up. But i really liked Rodney on the show .... you either love him or hate him i guess i have talked to a few people on here who dont like him at all. i thought his humour and the way he saved the day with the technlogy side was great. And the whole story with his sister was a good one aswell.

[Falcon Horus]

There were likeable moments (like with his sister, and with Cadman for example or just in the first 3 seasons), and then there were moments where I just wanted him to shut up and go away.

In the line of favorite characters, he has to settle with the second to last spot (Carter falls off the ladder, and Keller is barely hanging on at the end).

[Kenton-Atlantis]

YOU dont like Carter ??????? wow Amanda Tapping is great why?

[Falcon Horus]

YOU dont like Carter ??????? wow Amanda Tapping is great why?

Nope. Never really took to Carter on SG1 either. Don't know why really... she just didn't interest me much.

Love Helen Magnus (Sanctuary) though so it's definitely not AT's fault.

[Kenton-Atlantis]

Wow you see i thought she was great on SG-1. I thought that whole cast was great. i like Sanctuary aswell. Did you like her on SGA?

[Falcon Horus]

Did you like her on SGA?

Seeing as how I was a member of the Anti-Carter on SGA-thread, I guess you could say... not really.

[Kenton-Atlantis]

Wow i think she is great on everything she is on !! Great actor Samantha is the best female Character in Stargate

[Falcon Horus]

Wow i think she is great on everything she is on !! Great actor Samantha is the best female Character in Stargate

No, to me she's not...

And an actor can't always be great in everything they do. I can assure you that actors I love have made me cringe on one or two occasions already (f.e. Jewel as Keller, Claire in Vipers).
Like how I love AT as Helen but find her kind of meh as Carter.

The best female character in SG1 has to be Fraiser, in SGA possibly Weir though the female characters got the short end of the stick on too many occasions. And I don't watch SGU so can't comment there.

[Kenton-Atlantis]

I agree with you 100% that Weir was a good character and might have been the best. How come u dont like SGU. Its a really cool show a lot different from SG-1 and Atlantis!

[Falcon Horus]

How come u dont like SGU. Its a really cool show a lot different from SG-1 and Atlantis!

I'm happy you like SGU, it's just not something I'm interested in. And TPTB have burned their bridges with this fan - they are on my black list which basically means I don't intend on watching anything they had a hand in making. As far as I'm concerned they ruined the franchise.