Did anyone else feel kinda bad for Spencer?

[Deevil]

She said so in the trial

Yeah, back to my initial question - how do we know she didn't pick up on the problem anyway. After all, it wouldn't look good for Young is she reported he was a problem and he still had access to a weapon.

Mind you, given that we saw what everyone else saw Spencer do on the ship - how did no one pick up on the problem?

[jelgate]

Yeah, back to my initial question - how do we know she didn't pick up on the problem anyway. After all, it wouldn't look good for Young is she reported he was a problem and he still had access to a weapon.

Mind you, given that we saw what everyone else saw Spencer do on the ship - how did no one pick up on the problem?

I guess we really don't. TJ could have recognized the problem and ignored but I don't think she did that. She seems like a firm believer in the Hippocratic Oath. To propose what you are suggesting would be a major violation.

Most of the Destiny thought it was stress or maybe he acted simlair on Icarus

[Deevil]

I guess we really don't. TJ could have recognized the problem and ignored but I don't think she did that. She seems like a firm believer in the Hippocratic Oath. To propose what you are suggesting would be a major violation.

I didn't say that TJ ignored the problem, I said that Young ignored the problem (potentially). Also, I don't believe medics that the hippocratic oath, so no violation could have occured.

Most of the Destiny thought it was stress or maybe he acted simlair on Icarus

I agree with that 100%. I'm just saying though that TJ is not at fault for not doing anything here - because technically there was not much she could do.

[jelgate]

I didn't say that TJ ignored the problem, I said that Young ignored the problem (potentially). Also, I don't believe medics that the hippocratic oath, so no violation could have occured.

I don't believe that for a second. Thier is only so much that can be done to keep a person in line

I agree with that 100%. I'm just saying though that TJ is not at fault for not doing anything here - because technically there was not much she could do.

With drug addiction thier is not much anyone can do unless the addicted wants help

[Deevil]

I don't believe that for a second. Thier is only so much that can be done to keep a person in line

A guy with a drug addiction and temper problem should not be allowed access to guns!

With drug addiction thier is not much anyone can do unless the addicted wants help

True, but like I said above you can minimise their threat to others.

[jelgate]

A guy with a drug addiction and temper problem should not be allowed access to guns!

The drug addiction as far as canon evidence goes was unknown. As for a temper I think it matters more whats the cause of said temper. Greer has quite a temper but thier is no one I rather have protecting me.

[Deevil]

The drug addiction as far as canon evidence goes was unknown. As for a temper I think it matters more whats the cause of said temper. Greer has quite a temper but thier is no one I rather have protecting me.

Umm, no, wouldn't want Greer protecting me. It's too easy to set him off. Spencer was worse, much much worse. Not so much in temper, but in erratic behaviour. His actions in Light is testiment to that... Seriously, if they didn't realise he had a problem they are stupid. If they recognised he has a problem and still let him near weapons they are dangerous.

[Joachim]

sorta like Riley has vanished into the woodwork and nobody thnks or says anything about those two that went through the gate on the desert planet

I do. |:

[xxxevilgrinxxx]

...

Most of the Destiny thought it was stress or maybe he acted simlair on Icarus

The drug addiction as far as canon evidence goes was unknown. As for a temper I think it matters more whats the cause of said temper. Greer has quite a temper but thier is no one I rather have protecting me.

temper is something quite a few people on the show have shown (Rush. Young. Greer). I agree that Spencer seems to have exceeded that but, if he hadn't have killed himself, would we be thinking that? Or maybe waiting for him to give his head a shake and get down to the business of surviving. I suppose I mean to say that his behavior stands out because it led to him taking his life. Would it be looked at differently if he hadn't?

with the addiction, that can be something hard to spot, even with people trained to do so, and, like temper etc, it stands out after he's dead, but not so much beforehand

[jelgate]

temper is something quite a few people on the show have shown (Rush. Young. Greer). I agree that Spencer seems to have exceeded that but, if he hadn't have killed himself, would we be thinking that? Or maybe waiting for him to give his head a shake and get down to the business of surviving. I suppose I mean to say that his behavior stands out because it led to him taking his life. Would it be looked at differently if he hadn't?[

Hindsight is 20/20. Its obvious now to say Spencer was worse off then the other because of the suicide but was he temper more extreme then others. A lot of people were angry on the Destiny being stranded

[Deevil]

Hindsight is 20/20. Its obvious now to say Spencer was worse off then the other because of the suicide but was he temper more extreme then others. A lot of people were angry on the Destiny being stranded

You know I am not sure anyone who has shown a temper has been just because they are on Destiny, Greer showed signs of it before hand. Young did too... It's reasonable to assume that Spenser did as well. I can't help but wonder if there wasn't someone doing psych evals on these guys

[dacooker]

Yup, this guy was in a very bad spot, in a very bad way. He needed someone to spar with, beat the **** out of him daily to keep his sanity. However he seemed to distant for anyone to get to know him. Save Lt James attempts.

[Phantom6]

Danny boy kept getting killed throughout 10 seasons of SG-1

*English accent* He got better.

[rushy]

I don't feel sorry for Spencer at all. He was an idiot and everybody hated him. As Rush was forced to say:We're better of without him. Young should be the next one to go so Rush can come back.

[Pharaoh Atem]

if the story had been more deatiled and we got to see things from Spencer prescriptive then i would feel bad for him more.

[rushy]

I think Spencer would not have been a thief if it weren't for the med addiction.