Megathread - Versus battles

[Davidtourniquet]

I think Todd would easily beat Ba'al, Ba'al might be intelligent at hiding, but Todd is a good strategist and has the superior firepower.

[fugiman]

Well I think given the time and knowledge Ba'al would beat Todd but if it was just a bam smash right away fight then Todd has the advantage

[mickhhh]

how bout predator vs Blade

[kernl sandrs]

Now, knowing that it took those upgraded Asgard Beam weapons (seen in Unending) to take out an Ori Mothership, what makes you think a Wraith hive ship could even come close to matching that kind of firepower? Even a dozen of them, come on.

[Stewart5]

Now, knowing that it took those upgraded Asgard Beam weapons (seen in Unending) to take out an Ori Mothership, what makes you think a Wraith hive ship could even come close to matching that kind of firepower? Even a dozen of them, come on.

Well said. Well, well said.

[Kamosis]

Xenomorfos vs Unas?

[morrismike]

Sorry, that's right, from inside.

But the drones were still hammering it.

not really

[Stewart5]

Aye, they were. Doing much more damage than the Asgard beams, and actually managing to hold it back.

[fugiman]

Alright so who would win a fight Aphosis Ha'tak (the one that can go invisible), Anubis Superweapon or a Wraith Hive?

[Gormagon]

Xenomorfos vs Unas?

Pfft no contest. Xenomorph claws down.

how bout predator vs Blade

Thats a tougher one. If the Yautja (Predator) had his cloak, I do believe the Yautja would.-1, impale Blade with a launched spear to stun him, then slice off his head with his arm blades. Or, just go for the slice of head move by ambushing him well invisible.

Alright so who would win a fight Aphosis Ha'tak (the one that can go invisible), Anubis Superweapon or a Wraith Hive?

Wraith Hive would make good space dust in that fight. Having no shields I see Anubis's super weapon 1 hit ko'ing it. If Apophis managed to ambush Anubis well his shields were down he could win with a few lucky shots, but Apophis's ships was just based on Goa'uld technology (Which is not really theirs but still.) well Anubis had Ancient technology.

Anubis's mothership VS the Scimitar.

[Gormagon]

How about this one, the Anubis's mothership VS the Scimitar.

[McAvoy]

Scimitar. There are already debates on SG-1 vs. Star Trek.

I only say that because of Scimitar's cloak. Things being equal that would be the deciding factor.

[Gormagon]

I would tend to agree, but if Anubis hit Scimitar with his "super arc" I think that would take care of the cloak. However, I believe it would be a tough and interesting fight. Let us compare four things from each vessel.
Shields.
Main weapons.
Hull.
Special.

The Anubis mothership.
Shields- Upgraded Goa'uld shields, and the shields generated by a standard Ha'tak vessel are capable of resisting a 1G.t Naquadah-enhanced Nuclear warhead with no apparent damage, and if at full strength can remain in the Corona of a blue giant Star(Were temperatures range 30,000-50,000 Kelvin.) from for up to ten hours without danger of crew exposure to dangerous levels of radiation. The Anubis shields are based on ancient technology, meaning they will be virtually immune to many less advanced weapons.

Main weapons-Estimated 180 upgraded staff cannons. Why? A normal Ha'tak has 60 standard staff cannons. So I compared the sizes and came up with that number.

Hull-Hardened naquadah alloy.

Special- Plasma arc weapon capable of destroying three Ha'tak in one discharge. Its unique effect being it can leap from target to target.

Scimitar.
Shields-Primary and secondary shields. What exactly this means I am unsure, but because of the energy cost to run two shield systems at once I would say the Scimitar simply has a backup emitter system. Or, the secondary layer is weak compared to the primary. Now, according to my math, the Scimitar had taken about 1200MT worth in damage when it was at 70%. So its total shield power would be about 3800m.t. give or take.

Main weapons-52 disruptor cannons. I would put Goa'uld blast cannons and disruptor cannons pretty close in terms off effectiveness. (I am not counting the photon torpedo launchers of the Scimitar or the naquadah bombs of the Anubis mothership because they were not seen used in the movie/show.)

Hull- Most likely a durnanium alloy.

Special-Can fire its disruptors when cloaked. I am not counting the Thalaron radiation emitters because they take so fraking long to charge up and because I do not think the Scimitar could use them when cloaked.

[Gormagon]

Ashrak VS Gregory the super Wraith.

Place your bets place your bets.

[Gormagon]

Teal'c VS Tyr Anasazi See also ^

[Mister Oragahn]

How about this one, the Anubis's mothership VS the Scimitar.

We know that those ships weren't built as sturdy as other Ha'taks: if a bolt would go through the shields, it would stand a large chance to deal massive damage and literally go through the entire superstructure, which never happens with Ha'taks.
I suspect Anubis built those ships with an emphasis on power generation and shields, not hull and armours. In a way, it's similar to Atlantis, which according to McKay was "remarkably fragile".
So, with shields down, it could very well get toasted very fast, especially since the Scimitar can attack cloaked.
If not, it will be a fight of attrition wherein I don't see the Scimitar ever managing to hurt Anubis' ship's shields. It's already above anything Ha'taks can hope to deliver, and a Ha'tak is already a monster of its own kind.
In theory, keeping a lock on the first known position of an enemy torpedo will provide information about the ship's position. Firing in that direction will lead to a hit, which would most likely result into a direct kill. The Scimitar's superstructure wasn't particularly strong at all. It counted on her shields and cloak.