'Identity' (518) General Discussion

[Pio42]

I really liked Keller in the other chick's outfit. It looked good on her. The Zelenka snark at the end was funny.

YUP YUP tat was pretty much the highlight of the ep for me

[pjt]

Sandra writes: “Why wasn’t Neeva’s body in a coma the way Daniel’s and Vala’s were when they linked with Harrid and Sallis?”

Answer: Although similar in most respects, this was a different version of the device.

http://josephmallozzi.wordpress.com/...n-frustration/

Awwww, man, I was sure they'd play the distance card...

Edit: Dmn, I de-lurked myself again, I've forgot I re-lurked already...

[Ikaros]

I really liked how Ronon figured out Keller wasn't Keller.

The guy knows his way around.....hehehhe

Rodney was starting to feel jealous, when he found them in her room,while Ronon was wondering if he had to knock her out......nice scene.

[Mitchell82]

I disagree.

As do I.

McKay said (it was McKay, right?) said it worked differently from the MW one. Not all phones, DVD players, computers, etc. work the same. Why wouldn't there be a variation within Ancient comm. devices? Maybe this one was built much later than the MW one.

Definitely agree here.

I liked this ep. Not a stellar show, but fun. Zelenka getting stabbed was a shock, and we thought TPTB had plans for Oliveri's character for S6, had we had one.

Agreed. While it wasn't a candidate for best episode it defintely was a very good one with good and unexpected plot twists.

I really liked Keller in the other chick's outfit. It looked good on her. The Zelenka snark at the end was funny.

I really liked how Ronon figured out Keller wasn't Keller.

Same here.

[Feli]

Did anyone else notice that the village magistrate was that British scientist from SG-1 in "Endgame" except with a beard in this one?

Uff. I can finally stop wrecking my brain trying to remember where I saw this actor before

[elizabethtorri]

I love this episode.

[Hermiiod]

I missed the first third of the episode and it took me the rest of the episode to grasp what the heck was happening.
This had to absolutely be the worst episode to start watching from the middle.

[Iawen]

This was a really good episode. I had a problem with the fact that Neeva could outrun Ronon, though, because she wasn't in her own body; she was in Keller's body. No way could Keller ever outrun Ronon.

I also don't like the continuity error with the device; they could have easily saved it by having the characters be surprised that Keller was in Neeva's body and speculate that Jarvis must have messed around with the device and that's why it worked differently. But it seems like a continuity error to me because all everyone knew about the device was the two experiences Daniel and Vala had had with it, so why would they have assumed Keller was in Neeva's body?

[Falcon Horus]

Congratulations to Identity for winning my personal "Lousiest episode of the season" Award.

This was just... ridiculously bad TV. *shakes head*

Cheers to:

* the blink and you'll miss her, Teyla.
* the ever practical Ronon
* Zelenka in the infirmary at the very end - there was spontaneous laughter in pretty much the same style as with the painting in Harmony - full-scale rolling over the floor laughter

Jeers to:

* badly rehashed SG1-tale - I definitely prefer the SG1-episodes over this
* You bring Carson back for this? *facepalm*
* Keller is not a member of the military so not an officer (she'd probably never even make it through basic training anyway)
* the way the reveal was at the beginning - you know starting with Neeva. I think this could have been better excuted if it had been Jennifer for a bit, especially when stabbing Zelenka and disposing of the evidence. And then reveal the taking-over-the-mind-thing which could have easily been done when Neeva pulled the gun out on Rodney.

Also, a psychologist wouldn't have gone amiss here, if only for a few seconds. But I don't mind Carson doing a Kate there.

[Mona SAX]

I loved it. Shame it ends .

[major davis]

Quite possibly the worst ep of sga ever

[jelgate]

Quite possibly the worst ep of sga ever

One word: Irresponsible

[Linda06]

One word: Irresponsible

Beileve it or not there are actually worse eps than the Irr eps

[jelgate]

Beileve it or not there are actually worse eps than the Irr eps

Well sure if we include SG1 but that one is the worst SGA episode in my book.

[Linda06]

Well sure if we include SG1 but that one is the worst SGA episode in my book.

No not including SG-1

Let's see...We have...

Harmony
Travellers
The Shrine
Brain storm
Identity (obviously )
Vegas

How's that for a few I would watch the Irr eps before any of those again

All just my opinion and not fact in case anyone gets the wrong idea

[Lythisrose]

No not including SG-1

Let's see...We have...

Harmony
Travellers
The Shrine
Brain storm
Identity (obviously )
Vegas

How's that for a few I would watch the Irr eps before any of those again

All just my opinion and not fact in case anyone gets the wrong idea

I get a kick out of people's likes and dislikes - we are all so different!
On your list you have three of my favorites:
Vegas (my favorite SG ep ever)
The Shrine (minus the last 30 seconds or so)
Harmony (for some reason )

and two that are my least favorites:
Brainstorm (number one of all time)
Identity
and the Irre eps are pretty sad too...

[Linda06]

I get a kick out of people's likes and dislikes - we are all so different!
On your list you have three of my favorites:
Vegas (my favorite SG ep ever)
The Shrine (minus the last 30 seconds or so)
Harmony (for some reason )

and two that are my least favorites:
Brainstorm (number one of all time)
Identity
and the Irre eps are pretty sad too...

hehe, just goes to show how different we all are.

Well no prizes for guessing why I hated Harmony Apart from the last few seconds It's got a miniature version of Rodney I....Well let's just say I don't like kids

And The shrine

Spoiler:

Well I so did not need another "oh Rodney is dying.....AGAIN" ep

I thought the Irr eps were pretty funny

Identity was just boring from start to finish

[mrscopterdoc]

Congratulations to Identity for winning my personal "Lousiest episode of the season" Award.

It ties with BS for me. Not even Sheppy could make up for these two eppies.

[maneth]

Not my fave but I thought it was okay. Although I do wonder why the body switches weren't shown in reverse on SG-1. It would have been funny to see a medieval person in the middle of all the SG-1 tech.

[NowIWillDestroyAbydos]

Okay episode, slightly better than average.

Is it me, or did it feel like Ronan wanted to beat someone up when you first see him in Keller's Quarters.

"Keller" looked like she was was playing around (pretending) when she sat down in that jumper.

The communication stones made a return, getting a little back-story before they appear in SGU.

Tomorrow, an alternate universe set in Vegas.