Don't Leave Carson!

[rsanchez]

I think this episode makes a great case as to why Carson should stay instead of Keller.Carson is a no nonsense, get business done kind of guy that Keller just hasn't been. Keller whines when we most need her, while Carson laughs in the face of danger. Finally, Carson makes a much better couple with Rodney than Keller does. For the movie, we should see Carson, not Keller.

[marty2006]

Aye we scots are a tough breed alright.

[jenks]

Ha ha

[Linda06]

Aye we scots are a tough breed alright.

Yep we are Now can we keep Carson please

[jelgate]

I think this episode makes a great case as to why Carson should stay instead of Keller.Carson is a no nonsense, get business done kind of guy that Keller just hasn't been. Keller whines when we most need her, while Carson laughs in the face of danger. Finally, Carson makes a much better couple with Rodney than Keller does. For the movie, we should see Carson, not Keller.

Ford would say different when he faced the Geni

[dasNdanger]

Carson is a disgrace to the medical profession, violating his Hippocratic Oath a hundred times over. He has harmed so many, not healed. He has used sentient beings as guinea pigs, he has been responsible for aiding in the deaths of thousands of people due to the hoffan drug that he helped develop, and now, he himself has used his medical knowledge to poison another. He is nothing more than a doctor of death, not of life.

I am very disappointed with his development, especially since his 'resurrection' - he is dark, he is spiteful...he is exactly what Michael created him to be, and I don't like it at all. In comparison, Keller is a perky breath of fresh air, at least, until she starts killing her patients, or using her medical knowledge as a weapon to harm, instead of as a tool to heal.


das

[Earthgate Ricky]

I am very disappointed with his development, especially since his 'resurrection' - he is dark, he is spiteful...he is exactly what Michael created him to be, and I don't like it at all. In comparison, Keller is a perky breath of fresh air, at least, until she starts killing her patients, or using her medical knowledge as a weapon to harm, instead of as a tool to heal.


das

His dark side is hot!
That's why Carson keep me watching SA!

[Linda06]

His dark side is hot!
That's why Carson keep me watching SA!

Every side of him is hot

[dasNdanger]

Every side of him is hot

Not as hot as this (painting by masterling):

Spoiler:

:-P**************************

das

[FallenAngelII]

Finally, Carson makes a much better couple with Rodney than Keller does.

McShep is the only true Atlantis pairing. But McBeckett is cute in its own right as well.

And, yes, I didn't miss Jennifer this episode at all. The episode was refreshingly enjoyable without any BS about Richard being reduced to a clown or Jennifer shoe-horned into the episode just for the sake of it or Love Triangle BS (from now on, it'll probably just be badly written ship BS).

It's the best episode in months. Yes, Jennifer's absence made that much of a difference.

[Linda06]

Not as hot as this (painting by masterling):

Spoiler:

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v5...sswraith2a.jpg

:-P**************************

das

Ok is it weird that I actually find that really cool

You better not let spikey see that

[dasNdanger]

Ok is it weird that I actually find that really cool

You better not let spikey see that

No worries, it'll be our little secret.


das

[MCH]

No worries, it'll be our little secret.


das

You'll be in trouble Das when she finds out.

Spoiler:

Better have a large mattress ready when she goes

THUNK.....

MCH

[dasNdanger]

You'll be in trouble Das when she finds out.

Spoiler:

Better have a large mattress ready when she goes

THUNK.....

MCH

I like how his bellybutton is just peeking out over the top of his waistband...


das

[rsanchez]

I am very disappointed with his development, especially since his 'resurrection' - he is dark, he is spiteful...he is exactly what Michael created him to be, and I don't like it at all. In comparison, Keller is a perky breath of fresh air, at least, until she starts killing her patients, or using her medical knowledge as a weapon to harm, instead of as a tool to heal.


das

That would be expected, since first of all, he's not the original Carson and second of all, he performed medical research, not treatment, for quite a while. But you can still see the old Beckett, most noticeably when he decided to challenge the Wraith instead of participating in their medical research. He chose to try to save himself and Rodney rather than kill countless humans. That's pretty doctor-like to me. Personally, I prefer a multidimensional Carson rather than the doctor who saves lives at all costs and is reluctant to fight.