Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Rodney Should Have died.

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    #91
    Originally posted by Zamboni View Post
    What? Why? There are worse things in the two galaxies than seeing Dr. McKay in the nude...

    For example, seeing Dr. McKay in the nude while being trapped under the ice and Sam is forced to huddle around him to keep everyone alive...


    ... while a wraith is watching with a smirk on his face



    ... while everyone else watching it on Youtube
    You are one twisted individual. *pictures a reverse situation of me hugging a naked sam*
    Proud Sam/Jack and Daniel/Vala and John/Teyla Shipper!
    "We're Americans! Shoot the guys following us!"
    Don S. Davis 1942-2008 R.I.P. My Friend.

    Comment


      #92
      Originally posted by Mitchell82 View Post
      You are one twisted individual. *pictures a reverse situation of me hugging a naked sam*
      Wouldn't the "reversed" situation dictate that you must be as far away from Sam as possible to stay alive? Afterall the original scenario is that they must huddle together to keep alive, therefore the reserve would require the opposite steps to achieve the same results...

      So no hugging Sam for you! Muwhahahah!

      Comment


        #93
        Originally posted by Zamboni View Post
        Wouldn't the "reversed" situation dictate that you must be as far away from Sam as possible to stay alive? Afterall the original scenario is that they must huddle together to keep alive, therefore the reserve would require the opposite steps to achieve the same results...

        So no hugging Sam for you! Muwhahahah!
        Damn you!
        Proud Sam/Jack and Daniel/Vala and John/Teyla Shipper!
        "We're Americans! Shoot the guys following us!"
        Don S. Davis 1942-2008 R.I.P. My Friend.

        Comment


          #94
          Originally posted by Wardog117 View Post
          If Rodney had died, there would have been a revolt even worse than when Carson did.
          Not from me

          Originally posted by Rac80 View Post
          HEAVEN FORBID!!! I would love to see mckay die!
          Here you go and here you go

          Originally posted by Mitchell82 View Post
          All she needed to do was create a small hole and she did it slow enough that any chips would be minor.
          Which is exactly what was impossible to do with the equipment she had unless A LOT of physical force was involved - the kind of physical force that crushes human skulls

          Comment


            #95
            oh for gods sake some of ur people drive me insane stop bludey complaining if he had been killed then there would have been a petition to save him and a whole big campaign ie becket but even when he survives u complain looking at the shrine topics is basically a bunch of fans dissecting the ep and complaining about any little detail slightly off base and some that ppl just want to complain for no reason i mean seriously it was a gd ep but of course they arent guna kill rodney off that would be retarted u wonder why it gets cancelled what impression do u think sci-fi would get from reading these forums that the stargate elite arent happy
            stop complaining and just watch the damn show


            key members of parliament, key. The minds behind every military, diplomatic and covert operation in the galaxy and you put them in a room with a psychic.

            sigpic

            thanks to stef for making this banner

            Comment


              #96
              I personally thought that drilling a hole in his head in a dark, damp cave was pretty farfetched. As lets face it, he could have got infected or died. As its a dangerous operation to say the least and the thing coming out maybe saved him at the end of the day, but it was still pretty farfetched. Anyway, I'm glad he didn't die and it was an okay episode.
              sigpic

              Comment


                #97
                Originally posted by Cory Holmes View Post
                I agree that if they were going to kill off McKay, then this would have been the episode to do it in. It was all set up so perfectly.

                I'm glad they didn't, though.
                Absolutely perfect, especially with a last supper style ending of all them round the table, with flash back of their past adventures. It would of made it the greatest episode ever.

                Unfortunately SGA writers lack the bulls to kill someone off permanently

                Unfortunately the rather predictable ending also nudge it down a level or two. the ending seem to off take all the emotions/ drama out of the rest of the episode. But that just me.

                Whole and if the writer kill him they would not able to leave the studio or their houses with out armed escort, through I would not particularly care if they did kill him off.

                Comment


                  #98
                  I think as Atlatnis has proved from Season 1, they are willing to "kill" off characters and get rid of characters. Weir, Carson, Ford etc, but getting rid of Rodney wouldn't really have worked anyway. As at least with Ford he's just a soldier and is easily replaced with Ronan. He wasn't develop, whereas with Rodney killing him off and replacing him is not so easy. I can't imagine Zalenka as the team memeber, plus ti would mean bringing in another character to develop them in series 5 a major time for them. So it wouldn't have worked, to say they lack the balls is incorrect, they have got rid of characters before and would get rid of them if the time was right and it benefitted the show.

                  But ridding Atlantis of Rodney, would not have been a good thing. It would be like killing of Carter in SG1 or Daniel. It would be suicide for the show.
                  sigpic

                  Comment


                    #99
                    Originally posted by Mike1989 View Post
                    I think as Atlatnis has proved from Season 1, they are willing to "kill" off characters and get rid of characters. Weir, Carson, Ford etc, but getting rid of Rodney wouldn't really have worked anyway. As at least with Ford he's just a soldier and is easily replaced with Ronan. He wasn't develop, whereas with Rodney killing him off and replacing him is not so easy. I can't imagine Zalenka as the team memeber, plus ti would mean bringing in another character to develop them in series 5 a major time for them. So it wouldn't have worked, to say they lack the balls is incorrect, they have got rid of characters before and would get rid of them if the time was right and it benefitted the show.

                    But ridding Atlantis of Rodney, would not have been a good thing. It would be like killing of Carter in SG1 or Daniel. It would be suicide for the show.
                    So true. Killing Rodney would have been suicide for the show. PLus he's too nice

                    They should make Rodney sick more often. He is so sweet when he is dying.
                    "Wøøf!"

                    Comment


                      Originally posted by Muh_tuttles View Post
                      So true. Killing Rodney would have been suicide for the show. PLus he's too nice
                      They should make Rodney sick more often. He is so sweet when he is dying.
                      What show have you been watching?
                      Originally posted by aretood2
                      Jelgate is right

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      X