the fifth Race

[geb]

In the fifth race the asgaard said we could become join the alliance when weve proved ourselves.I was thinking whats the point when the ancients are not around anymore as the asgaard have said many times and weve never met the furling so what would be the point in joining the alliance.

Also the stargate timeline has so many contradictions its unbelivable. Atlantis left Earth over 5 million years ago to go the pegasus galaxy. I presume the alliance was before they left which means the asgaard must have been pretty advanced to interact with the ancients all those years ago.So what have they been doing for the past 5million years because theyre not much more advanced than the goauld.(for the amount of time theyve been around compared to the goauld)

[Xenan]

There is still the Nox who are pretty advanced, so why wouldn't we want to become their allies.

And we don't know how old the Asgard really are.

[Elwe Singollo]

There is still the Nox who are pretty advanced, so why would we want to become their allies.

Im confused on what your saying about the Nox. They are advanced, so we shouldn't become their allies?

[aAnubiSs]

Im confused on what your saying about the Nox. They are advanced, so we shouldn't become their allies?

He's probably on drugs!

[Xenan]

lol

I changed windows when I was typing and forgot to add the n't

I'm saying that if the Asgard and the Nox want us to become the fifth race and since they both are very advanced (Imagine the stuff we could learn), why shouldn't we take them up on that offer?

[Elwe Singollo]

I'm saying that if the Asgard and the Nox want us to become the fifth race and since they both are very advanced (Imagine the stuff we could learn), why shouldn't we take them up on that offer?

Oh, haha, your original post sounded like we shouldn't. I don't think its up to us if we want to become their allies, its really up to the Asgard and the Nox because they are the ones who are already in the alliance.

[aAnubiSs]

The SGC might be ready for it, the the rest of the world isn't.

[DownFallAngel]

The Asgard never said that they never met the furlings. Where did you get that from?

Also, Atlantis landed in the Pegasus Galaxy, after seeding the starts with gates. When Atlantis was sunken, the Ancients gated back to the MW, and continued their allaince...

[SaberBlade]

The Asgard never said that they never met the furlings. Where did you get that from?

in season 1, SG-1 came across a planet where 4 alien races meet and in season 2 when Jack got the ancient knowledge in his head for the first time the asgard there was an alliance of 4 great races, the ancient, the nox, the furling and the asgard so they have meet since they had an alliance with them

[Elwe Singollo]

I think the original poster said 'we haven't', not the Asgard.

[DownFallAngel]

I know about the alliance. I've seen both episodes. The Torrment Of Tantalus, and The FIfth Race.

WHen jack is gated to Othalla in the Ida Galaxy, the Asgard explain the allaince.

Asgard: The Ancients
Jack: Haven't met them
Asgard: The Nox
Jack: Met them
Asgard: The Furlings
Jack: Haven't met them
Asgard: And the Asgard
Jack: heard nothing but good things

[Selmak]

Asgard: The Ancients
Jack: Haven't met them

I don't think that was the exact quote.

[SaberBlade]

i think Jack said "don't know them" when it came to the Ancients

[DownFallAngel]

Selmak it was a paraphrase. There are no transcripts for SG1 really.

[Xenan]

I think he said that the ancients were a 'Pretty heady group'. But I could be wrong