Star Trek Ships vs. Stargate Ships

[Zues]

Star trek would definately own any stargate ship I mean come on they have PHOTON TORPEDOES! PHASERS ! Highest speed is Warp 9.6 on the U.S.S NC17-D Enterprise (Jean Luc Picards ship)! Anyhow a the G'ould motherships travel at like 30x the speed of light. However Warp speed is a factor of light speed so warp 9.0 is around 1,500 times the speed of light. (thats fast!) But yah you can't compare a deathglider vs a shuttle pod lol.

[Atlantis_Man]

I haven't seen the 9th Season on SG1 yet, but if the Ori rival the Ancients would that not mean that the Ori Ships would perform similarly to the Ancients and tus whoop Trek ass?

[david2708]

Even though I am I star Trek fan, this is an honest answer, considering time of development and such. Assuming this is all one on one...

Ancients Vs Star Trek = Duh, Ancient

More like Ancients Vs Q Continuum= Ancients are toast!!

As for ship battles:
Trek ships would do over Stargate rustbuckets in the blink of an eye.

[DHD]

Yes at the very least Q (John DeLance) could give the anchients a sense of humor. But I still say A Asgard ship would decinate ANY Startrek ship hands down. And if they can't out shoot them, there is one certainty. They can out run them like no bodies business.

[Eoin]

Star trek would definately own any stargate ship I mean come on they have PHOTON TORPEDOES! PHASERS !

felger was designing a crappy looking laser thing and he compared it to a photon torpedo, and it was tiny compared to a PT,that must tell ya something about PT's .

Highest speed is Warp 9.6 on the U.S.S NC17-D Enterprise (Jean Luc Picards ship)! Anyhow a the G'ould motherships travel at like 30x the speed of light. However Warp speed is a factor of light speed so warp 9.0 is around 1,500 times the speed of light. (thats fast!) But yah you can't compare a deathglider vs a shuttle pod lol.

1,500x the speed of light you say....
Now instead of comparing star trek to the goa'uld ,lets compare it to the Asgard (din din dinnnn, din din din dinnn )
ok voyager got stranded in a differant part of the milky way and it was gona take 75 years to get back home, hmmmm.... thats an awful long time when it takes the Asgard a couple of minutes to travel to differant galaxies, that makes star trek speeds look rubbish....

[Jeffer]

felger was designing a crappy looking laser thing and he compared it to a photon torpedo, and it was tiny compared to a PT,that must tell ya something about PT's .

1,500x the speed of light you say....
Now instead of comparing star trek to the goa'uld ,lets compare it to the Asgard (din din dinnnn, din din din dinnn )
ok voyager got stranded in a differant part of the milky way and it was gona take 75 years to get back home, hmmmm.... thats an awful long time when it takes the Asgard a couple of minutes to travel to differant galaxies, that makes star trek speeds look rubbish....

They weren't in the MW they were in another part of the Universe in Trek they have 4 Quadrants of the Universe Alpha (which we are in) Gamma (were DS9 took place) Delta (were Voyager was) and I can't remember the Fourth but they def were not in the MW. and i know this because the Borg Home world (or space ) is not in the MW and they had to travel through it

[creed462]

Terk have better weapons then current earth ships, but they have a couple hundrend years on us.
Any one else it may be a toss up.

[Eoin]

They weren't in the MW they were in another part of the Universe in Trek they have 4 Quadrants of the Universe Alpha (which we are in) Gamma (were DS9 took place) Delta (were Voyager was) and I can't remember the Fourth but they def were not in the MW. and i know this because the Borg Home world (or space ) is not in the MW and they had to travel through it

Actually they were in the MW, they divided the milky way in 4 quadrants..

[Jeffer]

Actually they were in the MW, they divided the milky way in 4 quadrants..

So all that means is that in the Trek world the Galaxy is bigger

[Eoin]

So all that means is that in the Trek world the Galaxy is bigger

how??

[the Fifth Race]

I did this same thread about 6 months ago....

Star Trek ships would destroy anything (except maybe the Asgard ships) we or the Goa'uld have!. But Star Trek is set hundreds of years in the future, so its not a fair asessment. It's just to damn hard to compare the two shows ships against each other.

[jenks]

I thought 'warp 9' was 9 times the speed of light?

[Jeffer]

how??

Interstellar drift in 2378 would be greater then in 2005

[Tezzador]

I thought 'warp 9' was 9 times the speed of light?

It's exponential.

1,500x the speed of light you say....
Now instead of comparing star trek to the goa'uld ,lets compare it to the Asgard (din din dinnnn, din din din dinnn )
ok voyager got stranded in a differant part of the milky way and it was gona take 75 years to get back home, hmmmm.... thats an awful long time when it takes the Asgard a couple of minutes to travel to differant galaxies, that makes star trek speeds look rubbish....

Realistically and fairly, which is more realistic?

[Eoin]

Interstellar drift in 2378 would be greater then in 2005

It cant get all that bigger in just 300 years

Realistically and fairly, which is more realistic?

None of them, their just tv shows j/k
Since i dont really like star trek, i'd have to say that SG-1 is more realistic.

[Carl]

Starfleet VS SGC Ships = Starfleet (SGC Asgard shields are probably better than Starfleet shields but their weapons suck quite badly)

Starfleet VS Go'ould = Starfleet (I don't think the motherships would be upto beating both phasers, torpedoes and superior manevourability of Starfleet ships)

Starfleet VS Asgard = Asgard (Starfleet ships may be advanced... but they're not THAT advanced)

Starfleet VS Wraith = Starfleet (The lack of shielding on the Wraith's part makes them an easy target and I don't think "sheer numbers" will help them in this case)

[Carl]

It's exponential

Yeah, so in warp terms, Warp 1 is 1 time the speed of light, Warp 2 is 10 times, Warp 3 is 100 times ... 1,000, 10,000 etc. Up until Warp 10 which is infinate speed, capable of taking you anywhere in the universe in the blink of an eye.

[Thor's Pal]

Listen, we're all forgetting one minor detail in this battle.

"Who would be the good guys?"

The good guys are the ones that are going to win, hands down.

[dosed150]

you do realise the federation in star trek have mastered the use of zero point energy (think quantum torpodoes) and ancients didnt have warships the federation now do do so i think a federation ship could beat an ancient ship an by that also any of the other ships youve mentioned

[the Fifth Race]

I would put my money on those Starfleet ships that Capt. Janeway (at the end of the Voyager) series help design with "A Balde of Armour" shielding they came up with to stop anything the Borg threw at them. Not to mention those crazy energy torpedos that made swiss cheese out the cube ships. Those would take down anything we have seen so far in the SG franchise.

SPOLIERS...BEWARE...

It will be interesting to see what kind of ships we see in future SGAS episodes. Supposedly they do find some kind of mini BC type warship that the Ancients built in Atlantis in an upcoming episode this season.