Stargate: The Musical/Musical episode

[glasgowgurl]

Hello, sorry if this is already a thread-- I did check!!! Is it just me, being a musical fanatic, or do other people want to see a musical episode of Stargate SG1? I mean, really, they've been at it for almost 9 years now, isn't it about time to include some songs and dances? Just one episode, i can see it: SG1 arrives on strange planet and there is some kind of chemical in the air that makes them start to sing and dance! or, they arrive on strange planet and the people inhabiting that planet have a special way of communicating, by song, not by talking. It's quite possible when you think about the thousands of human civilisations out there, and really music and dance are such an important part of our own culture... anyone agree? Plus, most of the actors on the show have stage experience and most likely will have at least once been in a musical and might even have had vocal lessons, being classically trained and all. Get Sondheim in on it! ok, sorry again if it's already posted.
luv yas

[OrangeShipper]

OMG that would be AMAZING!! I'd never even thought of that!! That would be immense... In my happy little dreamworld, if I'm listening to music, I often imagine SG-1 singing it at like a SGC Christmas Party or something, kinda like kareoke. Maybe thats just me being sad though...
But yeah that would be very very cool, and really enjoyable!! Maybe along with my little idea, if O'Neill has a leaving party for leaving the SGC, perfect excuse! Or something like that. The culture communicating in song idea is very good though, I'd love to see it!!
And you're right, it would be so out of place. Ive always been aware of music in Stargate - the opening theme and music throughout is very good. Especially evident in the earlier series.
Great idea!!

Claire

[pinguino_89]

I'm agree with you, it could great funny to see a musical episode.
There is a thead about if Stargate will make 200 episodes, well, if it make it, a musical episode can be a way to celebrate it!

[Seshat]

I know you were joking, but please, dear gawd, no!!

[Qasim]

I know you were joking, but please, dear gawd, no!!

I agree completely

NO WAY

[SaberBlade]

if a musical episode was done i would personally hunt down and kill the writer, director and the guy who gave permission for the episode to be done.

i hate musicials, so much that i totally ignored the buffy musical episode

[PhilM]

Musical episodes are great for some types of shows, but I don't think it would work with Stargate. It isn't a comedy, and it takes itself much more seriously than Buffy ever did...

[yasureubetcha]

There was Urgo...

"Row, row, row your boat..."


"If you call that singing..."

[MartoufMarty]

Oh god no...

I don't know why they made the Buffy musical (even though it was actually very good).

I hate musicals and a Stargate musical would probably just ruin the show!

[NightGloom]

That would be a hilarious fanfic, but if they actually did it as a show, then I would lose all faith in... everything. But after what we heard in Urgo, do we really want there to be a musical episode? Plus, it's way overdone and cliche.

[MartoufMarty]

That would be a hilarious fanfic, but if they actually did it as a show, then I would lose all faith in... everything. But after what we heard in Urgo, do we really want there to be a musical episode? Plus, it's way overdone and cliche.

It would be funny and I would watch it...

I'd just never think of Stargate the same after it...

If done badly, that view could be bad...

[Qasim]

I'd just never think of Stargate the same after it...

[spg_1983]

oh god please no. i really hope this is a joke because that would be the worst thing ever to happen to the show, worse than ascension, worse than anything else i can think of.

[Klaitu]

Honestly?

I think that this is quite possibly the worst thing that could happen to SG-1. That's the kind of garbagge writing that belongs on Angel, Buffy, or Smallville.

[MartoufMarty]

And they better not have someone get turned into a puppet...

It worked on Angel, but never... NEVER on Stargate.