I suppose my real question is out of all the warrior races we have been introduced to throughout the world of science fiction,( not just the two franchises refered to in the title) which were the truest warrior's, the best fighters with the richest warrior code.and why. This goes for any warrior race from any show you feel fits the parameters
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
A Jaffa,Satedan,Klingon and Jem'Hadar walk into a bar, who walks out alive?
Collapse
X
-
I think the Jaffa would survive things that would kill alot of warrior races, because despite being proud warriors and prefering to play fair, they are very intelligent about it and don't live to fight to the death.
Jem'Hadar would do fight excellently because they are so forceful. But they live to fight because they were bred to fight as a way to earn their exist. In my opinion they are the swords of The Founders, rather than true warriors.
I don't know what a Satedan is; is it the species from Farscape? That guy seemed to have it rather together but lacked the greater freedom of the Jaffa...
I'd have to say the Klingon's are the greatest warriors in the title because they have the freedom to choose their path, but religiously (both literally and metaphorically) choose the path of the warrior.
The Jaffa are more than warriors, and the Jem'Hadar are less than it.With Superb-Caliber-Frag-Statistics-Explosions-Are-Delicious!!
-
Originally posted by Twilord View PostI think the Jaffa would survive things that would kill alot of warrior races, because despite being proud warriors and prefering to play fair, they are very intelligent about it and don't live to fight to the death.
Jem'Hadar would do fight excellently because they are so forceful. But they live to fight because they were bred to fight as a way to earn their exist. In my opinion they are the swords of The Founders, rather than true warriors.
I don't know what a Satedan is; is it the species from Farscape? That guy seemed to have it rather together but lacked the greater freedom of the Jaffa...
I'd have to say the Klingon's are the greatest warriors in the title because they have the freedom to choose their path, but religiously (both literally and metaphorically) choose the path of the warrior.
The Jaffa are more than warriors, and the Jem'Hadar are less than it.Never Leave A Man Behind...or a Jaffa for that matter
Comment
-
Originally posted by Snowman37 View PostGiven they are all fictional aliens, whoever the writer wants to win.sigpicALL THANKS TO THE WONDERFUL CREATOR OF THIS SIG GO TO R.I.G.A lie is just a truth that hasn't gone through conversion therapy yetThe truth isn't the truth
Comment
-
The Jaffa are willing to "cut and run", so are the Klingons, the only race presented that won't are the Jem'ha'dar because they believe they are already dead and only with victory will they live.sigpicALL THANKS TO THE WONDERFUL CREATOR OF THIS SIG GO TO R.I.G.A lie is just a truth that hasn't gone through conversion therapy yetThe truth isn't the truth
Comment
-
I'd go for Klingon too. They are individually strong, trained and culturally warriors. The problem with Jaffa is that whilst they are sometimes strong, i.e. those who survive and get promoted, the majority are cannon fodder during battles between warring Goa'uld (i.e. generals who don't care about their troops' survival).
Comment
-
Right I had a good think about this and as much as I love the jaffa I also feel the klingons are The more complete package when it comes to warrior races. The jaffa may claim to have a rich history and plenty of jaffa legends, but they are still in their infancy when it comes to individuality and history as they only recently obtained their freedom and have yet to find their feet as a nation and as a people in general. The jem' hadar ar in an even worse position as they r still slaves to the dominion and despite their strength they are completely dependant upon their ketrocell white, without which they would die, which brings us back to the jaffa, if they are tretonin using jaffa ( which their are a lot now) they would have the same problems as the jem' hadar with regards to needing meds to be all they can be. The setedans ( Ronans race sga) are all but extinct but I think have the next richest warrior mentality just behind the Klingons, but imo they make such a big deal of their warrior culture because they are all but extinct. And in the setedans case I think ronan was the exception by being so physically imposing, not to say the rest of his race were not tough but they were soldiers first whereas the klingons always were and Will be natural warriors, its in their blood, their history is inundated with rich tales of war and honour they are trained in all aspects of war from the earliest age and relish the opportunity to prove their worth in battle. So in conclusion, the klingons are the victors here with the jaffa a close second, but in terms of characters if it was tealc, ronan,worf and a jem'hadar commander in a fight, then tealc would win, cause hes tealc...Never Leave A Man Behind...or a Jaffa for that matter
Comment
-
Originally posted by sgelite View PostI suppose my real question is out of all the warrior races we have been introduced to throughout the world of science fiction,( not just the two franchises refered to in the title) which were the truest warrior's, the best fighters with the richest warrior code.and why. This goes for any warrior race from any show you feel fits the parametersO'Neill: So, what's your impression of Alar?
Teal'c: That he is concealing something.
O'Neill: Like what?
Teal'c: I am unsure. He is concealing it.
Comment
Comment