Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Lantean and Ori satallite weapons

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Lantean and Ori satallite weapons

    This is a Vs. discution this is which one is the better weapon and which one is more powerful.

    Lantean Satallite:
    can cut though a hive like a hot knife through butter
    does not require a ZPM
    very big

    Ori satallite weapon:
    went through the prometheuses asgard shields like a bullet through a slab of fat
    has shields
    need to recharge after each blast.
    sigpic
    Alt Reality Stargate Fanfic Click and coment
    STARGATE RESURRECTION

    #2
    The Ori one is clearly more powerfull, if crude.

    Comment


      #3
      Originally posted by General_Finley View Post
      This is a Vs. discution this is which one is the better weapon and which one is more powerful.

      Lantean Satallite:
      can cut though a hive like a hot knife through butter
      does not require a ZPM
      very big

      Ori satallite weapon:
      went through the prometheuses asgard shields like a bullet through a slab of fat
      has shields
      need to recharge after each blast.
      the lantean weapon no question. it would have been able to take out the 3 hives without a problem if it would have been fully opperational . and the ori weapon took 2 shots to blow up the promethius which is powered by naquada generators.
      STARGATE ROCKS

      THERE IS NO BETTER SHOW

      Comment


        #4
        Originally posted by General_Finley View Post
        This is a Vs. discution this is which one is the better weapon and which one is more powerful.

        Lantean Satallite:
        can cut though a hive like a hot knife through butter
        does not require a ZPM
        very big

        Ori satallite weapon:
        went through the prometheuses asgard shields like a bullet through a slab of fat
        has shields
        need to recharge after each blast.
        Personally I don't think there's enough evidence on the Ancient's satellite weapon to conclusively state which out of the two is better.
        We have no idea whether the Ancient's satellite would work on shields, it's great against a Hive's hull armor, but that doesn't really mean it would do the same to a shield.

        A Hive is several times the size of a Ha'Tak so it could take more than one shot from the Ori's beam pulse thing to kill a Hive, although IMO one shot could probably be enough to dig down far enough into a Hive to kill it.

        Comment


          #5
          the ancient one I think,
          it took several blast for the ori one to destroy the Prometheus but only one shot from the ancient to take out a Hive ship and the Prometheus shields are not the best asgard shields available

          Comment


            #6
            i'd go with the ori one, if - and only if - it had been build by a more advanced society as the thing was only this inefficient because it was build by a society in the 50's (if compared to us) of the last century.

            as for the ancient one, it is considered a hive killer, so we don't know if it would be able to penetrate any energy shielding (maybe it couldn't even destroy a hatak from season 1-4 of SG-1 (those not upgraded by Anubis/Baal or the replicators)) we don't know that.
            For the ori one we know that it has no realy problem with shields (maybe it would have if the Prometheus would have had better power generation, but that is just speculation!) and ship hulls based on alloys (if it could destroy a hive? i would say: Yes, but i don't know if it's shields can stand up to a hives return fire, because i assume it will take 2-4 shots to destroy one)

            greetings LAX

            Comment


              #7
              the Lantean Satallite without a doubt

              Comment


                #8
                Definitely the lantean. Ori killed Prometheus in 2 shots and there is a cooldown between each shot. Atlantean one could take down an Ori ship in 1 shot (probably)
                SIGN THE PETITION: http://www.savesgu.tv/petitions/mult...-sgu-petition/
                LIKE THE FACEBOOK PAGE: http://www.facebook.com/SaveSGU
                READ THE PLAN: http://forum.gateworld.net/threads/8...aving-Stargate
                Spread the word! Save the gate!

                Comment


                  #9
                  The ori satalite was built by people that were bearly capeable of making current day WMD's so therefore the tech in the satalite was inferiour to anything the Ori had avaliable to them.

                  And the Lantean one was SPECIFICALLY designed to destroy wraith tech, so it MIGHT not be able to stand upto MW ships, HOWEVER the ancients built it so it must be able to give a punch.

                  So i make my vote to the......... Ori satalite. Plain and simply because it was designed to cut through shields and if it had been built by someone like the Asgard and at a stretch earth it would have been allot better than the one we saw.

                  But i still hold the Lantean satalite in high regards because it could be powered by a car battery (joke), it used a buffer system (which had a small charge time) which ment it could power more than one weapon system at a time. So means it might have been capable of haveing a larger power scource (ZPM) and really kick a punch.
                  sigpic

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Indeed they made the atlantean specifically to fight Wraith but still, it is capable of much more than that. They built it to use against the Wraith but also to defend Atlantis so if we saw it fighting something bigger than a wraith ship, I'm sure it would win.
                    SIGN THE PETITION: http://www.savesgu.tv/petitions/mult...-sgu-petition/
                    LIKE THE FACEBOOK PAGE: http://www.facebook.com/SaveSGU
                    READ THE PLAN: http://forum.gateworld.net/threads/8...aving-Stargate
                    Spread the word! Save the gate!

                    Comment


                      #11
                      big does not mean much, if it can't cut through shields....we don't know how it would fair, but if we go by popular speculations (it being a Particle-Beam) then it would not do much against shields, but it would be devastating to armor of any kind

                      greetings LAX

                      Comment


                        #12
                        We don't know if the Lantean satellites beam would be effective against energy shields. It was however very effective against the hive ship. It was able to cut through the hive ship in one shot. The Asgard plasma beam weapon took several shots before it took out a Wraith cruiser. The Lantean satellite was also able to charge at a much faster rate than the Ori satellite. They were able to power the Lantean satellite with a naquadah generator. Also the Ori satellite has a major weakness. It needs to be powered by a station located on the planet. All they would have to do is destroy the station and the satellite is useless. We also don't know what kind of shields the Lantean satellite has. The satellite was damaged when they found it and because they had to reroute the power it was only able to fire once before it overloaded. If it was in full working condition it may have had some powerful shields. Also its original power source was damaged. If it still had its regular power source it may have been able to have powerful shields to protect the satellite, it would also be able to charge even quicker with its original power source. The Ori satellite however had a powerful shield capable of resisting the missiles that were fired at it. The Ori satellite beam was still pretty impressive. We need to know more about the Lantean satellites capabilities before we can compare it to the Ori satellite.
                        Last edited by StargateBuilder; 04 August 2009, 09:16 PM.

                        Comment


                          #13
                          there based on similar tech.
                          i say the lantian sattelite is the best, because we only see the ori sattelite 1 and that was'nt enough to make any guesses about it's defence capibility.

                          Comment


                            #14
                            The ori satalite was made using inferiour technology, so it was bound to have loads of flaw's

                            and the lantean satalite has no mentionable defencive capabilitys. Also it isn't known if the satalite can cut through shields

                            So combine the two if it will shut people up lol

                            have the defencive capabilitys of the ori one, aswell as the beam weapon, and the lantean satalite aswell have the best of both worlds lol
                            sigpic

                            Comment


                              #15
                              Why would the Lanteans build a satellite designed to defend their HQ that didn't have shields?

                              The Ori satellite couldn't bring down the Prometheus with less than 3 shots, the Lantean one easily cuts a Hive ship in half. The Lantean one is clearly more powerful, by a huge margin.

                              I see no reason to think the Lantean satellite would be ineffective against shields. Who's to say it won't cut through shields just as easily as Wraith hulls?
                              Robert Jastrow (self-proclaimed agnostic): "For the scientist who has lived by his faith in the power of reason, the story ends like a bad dream. He has scaled the mountains of ignorance; he is about to conquer the highest peak; as he pulls himself over the final rock, he is greeted by a band of theologians who have been sitting there for centuries."

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X