Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Season 5 opinion

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Season 5 opinion

    Ok I Forgot to say their were spoilers in the title( im very new) SO WATCH FOR SPOILERS


    Ok, I just wanted to voice my opinion and let other people voice their opinion about the already aired season 5 episodes. On a rating of 1-10 ( including .5) I will rate all the past episodes of season 5 and ask everybody that reads this to do it also. Thanks!!! here is what the numbers mean to me

    10) outstanding 9) amazing 7-8) pretty awsome ( but all stargate is awsome) 5-6) fair, probably won't rewatch 2-4) not good but i wont turn it off 0-1) I will probobly want to blow up my TV

    Now here is what I think

    Spoiler:
    Search and Rescue- 9
    The Seed- 7
    Broken ties- 9
    Daedalus varitions- 8.5(love the new race)
    Ghost in the Machine-8.5 (great way to tie up the story without tori)
    The Shrine-9(they did really well with the emotional scenes)
    Whispers-7(would make it 9 but vega died)
    The Queen-8
    Tracker-6.5
    First Contact-9
    The lost Tribe-8
    Outsiders-8.5
    Inquisition-7
    The Prodigal-9.5(would be 10 but the body and the hybrid-baby scene prevented it)
    Remanents-4.5(Lost all the impact when kolya was fake)
    Brain Storm-4(Nothing against Keller and Rodney but it really stunk)
    Last edited by major davis; 25 November 2008, 12:39 PM.
    sigpic

    #2
    I don remeber so much of the first episodes so in start with:

    Whispers-10
    The queen-9
    Tracker-7
    First contact-8,5
    The lost tribe-10
    Outsiders-7
    Inquisiton-6
    The prodigal-9
    Remants-6
    Brainstorm-0

    To the last I take:

    Daedalus varitions-7.5

    I know i Rank them high but Stargate are great!!!!!!!!!!
    “We could be a team. You could be my sidekick.”
    “Sidekick?”
    “Yeah, it’d be like Batman and Ronon. Has a nice ring to it.”
    “Yeah, you keep eating like that it’s going to be more like fatman.”

    Comment


      #3
      Originally posted by major davis View Post
      Ok, I just wanted to voice my opinion and let other people voice their opinion about the already aired season 5 episodes. On a rating of 1-10 ( including .5) I will rate all the past episodes of season 5 and ask everybody that reads this to do it also. Thanks!!! here is what the numbers mean to me

      10) outstanding 9) amazing 7-8) pretty awsome ( but all stargate is awsome) 5-6) fair, probably won't rewatch 2-4) not good but i wont turn it off 0-1) I will probobly want to blow up my TV

      Now here is what I think

      Search and Rescue- 9
      The Seed- 7
      Broken ties- 9
      Daedalus varitions- 8.5(love the new race)
      Ghost in the Machine-8.5 (great way to tie up the story without tori)
      The Shrine-9(they did really well with the emotional scenes)
      Whispers-7(would make it 9 but vega died)
      The Queen-8
      Tracker-6.5
      First Contact-9
      The lost Tribe-8
      Outsiders-8.5
      Inquisition-7
      The Prodigal-9.5(would be 10 but the body and the hybrid-baby scene prevented it)
      Remanents-4.5(Lost all the impact when kolya was fake)
      Brain Storm-4(Nothing against Keller and Rodney but it really stunk)
      You should really put a spoiler tag in here for those of us who still can't watch season 5 of SGA yet. I thought this was about SG1 because there were no tags.
      StarshineRoxie
      A woman that allows herself the balance of cool wisdom and strength of heart.
      sigpic

      Comment


        #4
        Spoiler:
        Search and Rescue- 8.5 (It was good, but I thought they could have done more with Sheppard and his desire to save Tey'la, plus they retconed a few things and that tore it down a notch)
        The Seed- 7
        Broken ties- 8 (Not a bad episode, but could have been done better)
        Daedalus varitions- 10 (IMO it was an amazing team based episode)
        Ghost in the Machine-8.5 (Wasn't that bad, just think it could have been done better in the end)
        The Shrine-10 (Great emotional episode)
        Whispers-4 (No offense to anyone who likes it but I thought it was one of the worst episodes I'd seen in a long time)
        The Queen-6 (Could have done so much more with Tey'la, it just fell flat to me)
        Tracker-6.5 (Wasn't that bad)
        First Contact-10 (Simply amazing)
        The lost Tribe-10 (Best two parter I've seen in Atlantis since The Storm)
        Outsiders-6 (Most of the stuff could be seen coming, and it just fell short)
        Inquisition-5 (Clip show, what can you say)
        The Prodigal-8.5 (Could have been better, but a few things fell short)
        Remanents- 9 (I loved it, when I first saw the Genii were on the mainland I was about to throw it out but they wrapped it all together very nicely)
        Brain Storm- 7 (It was a good episode, Keller and Rodney was a bit much but it wasn't bad)
        sigpic Current Episode: Hell's Fire
        Stargate Olympus Virtual Series
        Stargate Olympus thread
        Spoiler:


        Comment


          #5
          sorry, im very new to the forum, ill get right to it
          sigpic

          Comment


            #6
            Search and Rescue- 9
            The Seed- 8
            Broken ties- 8.5
            Daedalus varitions- 9.5
            Ghost in the Machine-9.5
            The Shrine-9
            Whispers-7
            The Queen-8.5
            Tracker- 8
            First Contact- 9.5
            The Lost Tribe - 10
            Outsiders- 9
            Inquisition- 7
            The Prodigal- 9.9999999
            Remnants- 8.5
            Brain Storm- 7.5
            sigpic

            Comment


              #7
              umm hey major, just a suggestion. Before you post look though the fourms for 10-20 min. there is probably something like this there. I Have done this many times so its ok. there are multiple of these but its ok, you're new

              sigpic
              Sig made by squirrely1
              http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dQw4w9WgXcQ
              *PM me if you clicked on that link*

              Comment


                #8
                Search and Rescue - 9
                The Seed - 7
                Broken ties - 8
                Daedalus Variations - 9
                Ghost in the Machine - 6
                The Shrine - 9
                Whispers - 7
                The Queen - 7
                Tracker - 7
                First Contact - 9
                The Lost Tribe - 9
                Outsiders - 6
                Inquisition - 8
                The Prodigal - 9
                Remnants - 8
                Brain Storm - 8

                Comment


                  #9
                  Looks like you guys have been liking this season more than I have. I don't feel right reducing each episode to a number, since that won't adequately explain how I feel about it so far, but if I had to, I would give the whole season to this point a 6. The only episodes I've really thought were that good are "The Shrine", "First Contact", and "The Lost Tribe".

                  In the premiere, I thought it was a good episode, but a pretty weak send-off for Carter who I think was integrated badly as a major character, if at all. Woolsey is utilized poorly as well and I really don't care much for Keller. She's still so awkward and unsure of what she's doing in the group and hasn't grown at all as a character, except in her relationship to McKay.

                  Generally, I feel that the show's writers never adapted to Tori Higginson and Paul McGillion quitting as central cast members in season 3 and failed to integrate the new characters in with the rest of the team. That and the fact I think anything new they can do with the material would be too little, too late even before the cancellation was official.

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Originally posted by NotDarkseid View Post
                    Generally, I feel that the show's writers never adapted to Tori Higginson and Paul McGillion quitting as central cast members in season 3 and failed to integrate the new characters in with the rest of the team. That and the fact I think anything new they can do with the material would be too little, too late even before the cancellation was official.
                    Neither quit

                    ----------

                    S&R: 10
                    The Seed: 9
                    BT: 6
                    DV: 8
                    GitM: 7.5
                    The Shrine: 7
                    Whispers: 5.5
                    The Queen: 8.5
                    Tracker: 2.5
                    First Contact: 8
                    TLT: 6.5
                    Outsiders: 7.5
                    Inquisition: 5
                    The Prodigal: 10
                    Remnants: 8
                    Brain Storm: 0
                    What we do in life echoes in eternity - Gladiator vghUp the Blades!

                    Comment


                      #11
                      S&R: 9.75
                      The Seed: 7
                      BT: 7
                      DV: 8.5
                      GitM: 6
                      The Shrine: 10
                      Whispers: 7
                      The Queen: 8
                      Tracker: 1
                      First Contact: 8.5
                      TLT: 5
                      Outsiders: 8
                      Inquisition: 5
                      The Prodigal: 10
                      Remnants: 8.5
                      Brain Storm: 0
                      sigpic

                      Comment


                        #12
                        Search & Rescue 10
                        The Seed 8
                        Broken Ties 8.5
                        Daedalus Variations 9.5
                        Ghost in the Machine 8
                        The Shrine 9.5
                        Whispers 7.5
                        The Queen 9
                        Tracker 7.5
                        First Contact 10
                        The Lost Tribe 9.5
                        Outsiders 9
                        Inquisition 7
                        The Prodigal 9.5
                        Remnants 9
                        Brain Storm 7.5
                        sigpic
                        The Sam Carter/Amanda Tapping Thunk thread The Sam/RepliCarter Ship Thread

                        Comment


                          #13
                          Spoiler:
                          Search & Rescue 7
                          The Seed 5
                          Broken Ties 6
                          Daedalus Variations 7
                          Ghost in the Machine 6
                          The Shrine 6
                          Whispers 6
                          The Queen 6
                          Tracker 7
                          First Contact 9 (only because Jackson is in this ep)
                          The Lost Tribe 9 (the Asgard twist was great)
                          Outsiders 6
                          Inquisition 6
                          The Prodigal 6
                          Remnants 6
                          Brain Storm 8.5 (somehow i really enjoyed this ep)
                          sigpic

                          Comment


                            #14
                            Spoiler:
                            Search & Rescue 6
                            The Seed 7
                            Broken Ties 6.5
                            Daedalus Variations 7
                            Ghost in the Machine 6.5
                            The Shrine 6
                            Whispers 7
                            The Queen 8
                            Tracker 5
                            First Contact 7.5
                            The Lost Tribe 2
                            Outsiders 9.5
                            Inquisition 7.5
                            The Prodigal 8
                            Remnants 7
                            Brain Storm 0


                            Looking back I remember some of the episodes a bit more fondly than I first thought (The Queen) Some I just want to forget (The Lost Tribe, Brainstorm - though 10 out of 10 for episode name, never have they come up with one more fitting) and the second half has been mostly better than the first (though the 2 worst episodes have come in the second half) but overall so far I'm afraid I'd say it's 6.5-7, distinctly average

                            Comment


                              #15
                              Here is my two cents worth

                              Search and Rescue 10
                              The Seed 3
                              Broken Ties 9
                              Daedalus Variations 10
                              Ghosts in the Machine 9
                              The Shrine 7 (Keller ruined it for me)
                              Whispers -800
                              The Queen 10
                              Tracker (Didn't watch)
                              First Contact 8
                              The Lost Tribe 2.9 (Keller strikes again)
                              Outsiders 9
                              Inquisition 3 (what was the point of Rodney,Ronon,Teyla being there)
                              Prodigal 10
                              Remnants 10
                              Brain Storm (didn't watch)
                              Why did you do such a thing, you mediocre dunces?

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X