Staff Cannon vs Railguns and missiles

[folke123]

I am just wondering who has the greater Fire power, a 304 or a Ha'tak? Before the Asgard upgrades of course

60 staff cannons vs 32 railguns and Mark missiles.

And if the Staff cannons are stronger than the railguns and Missiles
would it be enough? Considering that a 304 have supperior shields

Or do a Ha'tak have both lower fire power and worse shields? meaning they wouldn't stand a chance?

So my ultimate question is probably who would win. An unupgraded 304 or a ha'tak?

EDIT: This is totaly oftopic but, does it take some time from when you post a thread to when you can find it?

[folke123]

Nobody has anything to say I wan't to know

[stargater1990]

I am just wondering who has the greater Fire power, a 304 or a Ha'tak? Before the Asgard upgrades of course

60 staff cannons vs 32 railguns and Mark missiles.

And if the Staff cannons are stronger than the railguns and Missiles
would it be enough? Considering that a 304 have supperior shields

Or do a Ha'tak have both lower fire power and worse shields? meaning they wouldn't stand a chance?

So my ultimate question is probably who would win. An unupgraded 304 or a ha'tak?

EDIT: This is totaly oftopic but, does it take some time from when you post a thread to when you can find it?

actually, i have never seen a pre unending 304 destroy a hat'ak..... or for that matter a post unending one but i think that the goauld wepons are better than railguns and missils.

[stargater1990]

I am just wondering who has the greater Fire power, a 304 or a Ha'tak? Before the Asgard upgrades of course

60 staff cannons vs 32 railguns and Mark missiles.

And if the Staff cannons are stronger than the railguns and Missiles
would it be enough? Considering that a 304 have supperior shields

Or do a Ha'tak have both lower fire power and worse shields? meaning they wouldn't stand a chance?

So my ultimate question is probably who would win. An unupgraded 304 or a ha'tak?

EDIT: This is totaly oftopic but, does it take some time from when you post a thread to when you can find it?

actually as your a new member your posts have to be monitored and approved by a moderator before they are actually posted, here this is a link to what im talking about: http://forum.gateworld.net/showthread.php?t=58466 darren (the owner) explains it better than i do.

[2ndgenerationalteran]

as in damage done over time i think that the 32 rail guns may do more damage than 60 staff canons, the rate of fire is very high in comparison and each round does enough to make huge explosions when the hit the ground (the game) hataks fire a pulse every second or so

[Buba uognarf]

A Ha'tak doesn't have 60 staff canons Does it?

[folke123]

Acording to stargate wiki it does

[folke123]

Oh when we are the subject of ship versus ship fights, Goa'uld death glider vs 302?
they are built for the same thing but witch craft do you know/think is supperior and why?

[2ndgenerationalteran]

i dont think so but that so happens to be the number thrown out, but if point defenses were counted i wouldnt be that surprised.

[Buba uognarf]

i dont think so but that so happens to be the number thrown out, but if point defenses were counted i wouldnt be that surprised.

Well the shots it fires at small targets look pretty much the same as those fired at capital ships tbh.

[Zatnikitelman]

Remember in Off the Grid when Odyssey fired a small spread out burst across the Lucian ships? Marks reported minor DAMAGE to the ships. Not shield damage, but honest to goodness damage, and yes the shields were up. Railguns are powerful enough to take down several Ha'taks!

[Mister Oragahn]

Acording to stargate wiki it does

Yeah yeah, well these guys use disputable sources.
By looking at the episodes, Ha'taks would seem to have between 12 and 24 main guns, and the rest being point defense guns which can actually be dialed up high enough to threaten buildings (or maybe that the main guns being dialed down).

There's nothing firm on that.

What's sure, however, is that aside from their nukes, 304s were piss poor weak before the addition of the instant win beams.

[s09119]

Remember in Off the Grid when Odyssey fired a small spread out burst across the Lucian ships? Marks reported minor DAMAGE to the ships. Not shield damage, but honest to goodness damage, and yes the shields were up. Railguns are powerful enough to take down several Ha'taks!

He probably meant damage to the shields. As far as we know, drones are the only weapons that pass through shields, and if railguns could we would definitely have been told.

[ManiacMike]

He probably meant damage to the shields. As far as we know, drones are the only weapons that pass through shields, and if railguns could we would definitely have been told.

thrown knives

[stargater1990]

Oh when we are the subject of ship versus ship fights, Goa'uld death glider vs 302?
they are built for the same thing but witch craft do you know/think is supperior and why?

the 302, because in fallen oniell was able to take out multiple death gliders single handedly and since the 302s have a hyperspace window generator, they can make very short jumps, which was eneough to bypass the goaulds shields. no glider can do that.