Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Deadalus vs Enterprise vs BSG

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Deadalus vs Enterprise vs BSG

    ok guys I dont know if this has been posted before but here gos.
    another battle thread who would win Deadalus/Odyssy(?) Enterprise (any or all) or the Battlestar Galactica.

    what i think will be posted soon
    SUCK IT P90

    hes shooting bunnies so cute give him a G36 and he'll be shooting bears

    #2
    well.. Galactica would be taken out first.. (No shields.. crappy weapons and so on)

    So the fight would be between what ever 304 and the Enterprise..
    but i would give the prize to the 304..
    we have never seen any enterprise cut thrugh anemy shield and punched a hole in their ship with one shoot..


    but all 304's can now do that
    Also i think the Ori Toilet ships have alot more powerfull beam weapon than what any Federation ship have.. and the 304's shiled eats that up like candy

    Comment


      #3
      well. lets see.

      oddy VS BSG.

      oddy is smart.

      oddy maneuvers around BSG, opening fire with railguns and plasma beam weapons, rapidly destroying the fighter bays, then taking on the craft and defeating it within a single maneuver.

      oddy is dumb.

      oddy floats silently, pounding at the BSG. the BSG opens fire too, launches vipers
      oddy launches 302's. the 302's are rapidly defeated, but the BSG has been destroyed. then, the oddy's railguns take out the vipers



      oddy VS enterprise.

      one beam penetrates the sauces, the second the warpdrive, causing a cataclysmic explosion from the antimatter reactor, and annihilates the craft. oddy wins

      Comment


        #4
        well i do beleive that bsg would be blown out of the sky by the enterprise and deadalus then the deadalus would mop up the vipers with rail guns (yes they still have them i think caldwell forgot about em) then i would have to go with the latest enterprise wich would barrage the deadaluses shields with photon and quantum torpedos while the deadalus begins draining the enterpises shields with asgard beams until it puts a few holes in it disableing it while it fires a few nukes obliterating it.

        next all three fleets vs each other.
        SUCK IT P90

        hes shooting bunnies so cute give him a G36 and he'll be shooting bears

        Comment


          #5
          Originally posted by thekillman View Post
          well. lets see.

          oddy VS BSG.

          oddy is smart.

          oddy maneuvers around BSG, opening fire with railguns and plasma beam weapons, rapidly destroying the fighter bays, then taking on the craft and defeating it within a single maneuver.

          oddy is dumb.

          oddy floats silently, pounding at the BSG. the BSG opens fire too, launches vipers
          oddy launches 302's. the 302's are rapidly defeated, but the BSG has been destroyed. then, the oddy's railguns take out the vipers



          oddy VS enterprise.

          one beam penetrates the sauces, the second the warpdrive, causing a cataclysmic explosion from the antimatter reactor, and annihilates the craft. oddy wins
          for the sake of a good story lets say the beam weapons take about 3 shots to drain shields and then about 2 to blow up ent.
          SUCK IT P90

          hes shooting bunnies so cute give him a G36 and he'll be shooting bears

          Comment


            #6
            ok with the appolo deadalus and oddyssy vs all of the enterprises vs the bsg fleet with bsg and bsp with the whole civ fleet who would win... i have an idea

            Spoiler:
            ok the A.D.O with all the enterprises would take out the weak first bsg and bsp would be destroyed momentarily with the only casulty being Archers enterprise wich had a glitch in its navigation and ran into a bsg civ ship (mayweather was getting coffee) then the A.D.O engage the enterprises they blow up kirks enterprise while he is in his room with his shirt off already having a romantic affair with an alien the blast from the ship knocks the appolo into another civ ship which obliterates on contact with apollos shields while the picards finish it off. then deadalus and oddyssy blow up the enterpriuse b before it falls into a rift in time then the picards are all thats left with the deadalus and oddyssy on one side and the enterprises on the other stairing down each other.
            suddenly 3 hatacks come out of hyperspace
            while 3 klingon ships decloak next to the enterprises
            then they attack each other the oddyssy and deadalus blow em up while the jaffa power up
            the end
            SUCK IT P90

            hes shooting bunnies so cute give him a G36 and he'll be shooting bears

            Comment


              #7
              The Enterprise E, the new one would take out the 304 using its quantum torpedoes. Ok the 304 would probably disable the shields but the enterprise would finally win. Sorry BSG but you would be detroyd from a 304 shot or a torpedo

              Comment


                #8
                Battlestars wouldn't stand a chance in this the only advantage they ave is there FTL drive (Can apear anywere in a short range, So it can jump inside Oddysey and KABOOOM). The bigest advantage they have is the Vipers they would beat any other fighter in the universe with manuevorabiility speed and better training, They would probably run circles around 304's but would eventualy be wiped out as they can't drain shields well enough. The only ship a battlestar would be able to take out would be Archers Enterprise or any other ship that looses shields in the battle.

                The best way for the Enterprises to win would be to sacriface one of there number and use the sensor telemitry from the battle to adapt there shields to better withstand beam weapons. They would probably need to go away for a few days to adapt them. Archers Enterprise only has 1 advantage its security personal, They've had alot of experience in ship board fights and the Maco's and Malcolm would be able to capture a 304 if its sheilds were down. They probably couldn't take a battlestar though considering they are packed with 2000+ military personal. The next advantage Starfleet ships have is there internal forcefields, Replicators and small arms no SG or Colonial team would be able to board them and get very far. Also there construction is so much better than 304's as we've seen in Enterprise, Nemesis and Generations Enterprise can take a huge beating without shields as we saw in 'Azati Prime/ Damage' Enterprise D survived its suacer section crash landing on a planet and Enterprise E rammed the Scimitar in Nemesis and survived very well.

                The 304's have 2 advantages there beam weapons and there speed. They could beat any ship in a FTL race over long distance (Wouldn't beat a battlestar over short distance as they jump instantaniosly). The beam weapons would cut Galactica and Pegasus in half easily and the best way to take them down would be to aviod Pegasus forwar batteries as I would imagine they would still do alot of damage even to shields. 304's are pointless in the auxilary craft fight Vipers would win without a doubt and Federation shuttles have good speed, shields and there Phasors would be brilliant at taking out fighters.

                Pretty close between the Enterprises and 304's but against the Oddysey they wouldn't stand a chance unless they had several Defiant class's with them, All the Enterprises need to do is stay behind the 304's as we haven't seen any rear firing beams yet and there is more evidence to prove that they don't have them than they do. But against more than 1 304 they couldn't stay out of the beams firing arc.
                if it wasnt for Carters new plot shield we would be dead


                Comment


                  #9
                  oh i forgot:

                  oddy beams nuke onto BSG.

                  oddy takes out enterprise shields, and beams a nuke on. or actually, beams a nuke directly on as their shields wont protect gainst out beam transporters. forget bout security teams: just beam out everyone off the ship, then board it

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Originally posted by thekillman View Post
                    oh i forgot:

                    oddy beams nuke onto BSG.

                    oddy takes out enterprise shields, and beams a nuke on. or actually, beams a nuke directly on as their shields wont protect gainst out beam transporters. forget bout security teams: just beam out everyone off the ship, then board it
                    Why haven't they done it to Goauld Hataks, Assuran Auroras or the unprotected hives in the start of seige part 3 ???. Also Starlfeet has transporters and they would most likely use them the same way, We've seen them beam teams on to place demo charges on structural supports before (Enterprise 'Regeneration').

                    Any team trying to get onboard a Starfleet ship won't get far as all Federation ships apart from the earlier ones (Archers through to Kirks) have internal forcefields and structural containment fields which limits some explosions internally. The 2 best targets to go for are the Warp core and the bridge which are easily destroyed in earlier ships (Archers Enterprise lost it's bridge in an ulternate time line easily 'Twilight'), But that flaw has been corrected in newer ships as we saw in Nemesis were internal forcefields contained the huge whole in the side of the bridge.

                    Remeber Starfleet ships aren't war ships they are designed for exploration and being able to defend themselves so there sensors will be much much more powerful than anything 304's and Battlestars have. Also they can be fitted with external hologram emiters to show other Federation ships out there. And railguns don't work as all dumb projectile weapons will be forced away by the deflector which is why there obsolete in Star trek universe (Doesn't count for torpedoes as they aren't dumb).
                    if it wasnt for Carters new plot shield we would be dead


                    Comment


                      #11
                      mm. how do you know their sensors are better? oddy has asgard level, "look through goauld shields" sensors.

                      and boarding wont help, no. just beam everyone off the ship, and beam into the bridge. or just shoot the warpdrive, and the thing is down.

                      Comment


                        #12
                        Originally posted by thekillman View Post
                        mm. how do you know their sensors are better? oddy has asgard level, "look through goauld shields" sensors.

                        and boarding wont help, no. just beam everyone off the ship, and beam into the bridge. or just shoot the warpdrive, and the thing is down.
                        One problem with shooting the warpdrive it will cause an explosion similar to the rigged ZPM.

                        Enterprise E would still win.... deplete all the quantum torpedoes into the oddy and KABOOOM!!!

                        Comment


                          #13
                          Then it's left weaponless to the Daedalus, Phoenix, Apollo and Prometheus (if you are including every ST craft why not every SG craft?). Oh, and while your at it Anubis' superweapon will have charged.
                          Originally posted by Craig Charles
                          "And the 'replicator' has just entered Sir Killalot's corner and Killalot is...urm...wait a minute... Sir Killalot has just been eaten by the 'replicator' and now there's two of them..."

                          Comment


                            #14
                            ok heres the figures to work with
                            SG has Prometheus, Oddyssy, Deadalus, Koralev, Pheonix.
                            ST has Archer, Kirk, Picard, Picard, Janeway (its ST)
                            BSG has BSG, BSP, CIVILIAN FLEET

                            and while were at it who would win a ground war (BSG doesnt count lol)
                            SUCK IT P90

                            hes shooting bunnies so cute give him a G36 and he'll be shooting bears

                            Comment


                              #15
                              The Enterprise E would win over a 304. In at least one and possibly more episodes of STTNG the E-D was able to sit inside the Corona of a star. Considering that the E shields are stronger than the D's and the 304's can't get near the corona without killing the crew. Remember the episode where the wraith virus infected the Daedalus and tried to steer the Daedalus into a close flyby of a stars corona to kill the crew. The 304's at that time had the same shields as the Asgard. Remember we lost a 304 and an Asgard ship was lost when the Ori came through the supergate

                              I think the Galactica would eventually loose but it might hold out for a while. Its armour is substantial Remember the Galactica has survived direct hits with nukes

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X