Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Crossing to Atlantis- Carter FAIR & BALANCED | SPOILERS

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Crossing to Atlantis- Carter FAIR & BALANCED | SPOILERS

    Why is every thread either "HATE CARTER" or "LOVE CARTER"?

    Here now is a new thread to discuss whether or not you think you will like or dislike Colonel (promoted from LtCOL) Carter on Stargate: Atlantis.

    No flaming or personal attacks allowed. Just present your arguments for or against having Carter.

    Once the character appears on Atlantis for a couple of weeks, then a new thread will appear:

    "Carter: FAIR and BALANCED- Pros and Cons for Being Onboard | SPOLIERS"
    Once a MARINE, Always a MARINE

    God Bless, Protect, and Speed,


    Robert Emmett Stephen Doyle IX


    Irish by ancestry, American by birth, but MARINE by the grace of God.
    Fortitudine Vincit, In Deo Speramus, Semper Fidelis

    SEMPERTOONS: http://www.sempertoons.com/
    SEMPERTOONS Store: www.cafepress.com/sempertoons

    #2
    For me, im not sure one way or the other on how i feel about Carter coming on board the show.

    People blame Amanda Tapping for Tori Higginson leaving, but Tori wanted out from the series. This not commonly known. They arrived at a medium of a reduced role for Tori. Amanda's role is for 10 episodes, half of the season.

    There have been many reversed roles, SG-1 and Atlantis characters on the other show, in the Stargate universe. Its nothing new.

    Major character changes have happened on SG-1: -Daniel Jackson. +Jonas Quinn. -Jonas Quinn. +Daniel Jackson. -BGEN Jonathan 'Jack' O'Neill. +MajGEN Hank Landry. +COL Cameron Mitchell. +Vala Mal Doran. +MajGEN George Hammond. +/-BGEN/MajGEN Jonathan 'Jack' O'Neill. +/-Dr Rodney McKay. +/-Dr Elizabeth Weir.

    Major character changes have happened on Atlantis: -COL Marshall Sumner. +/-Lt Aiden Ford. +Ronon Dex. -Lt Aiden Ford. +COL Steven Caldwell. +/-LtCOL Samamtha Carter. +/-BGEN/MajGEN Jonathan 'Jack' O'Neill. +/-Walter Harriman. +/-MajGEN Hank Landry. +/-Dr Daniel Jackson.

    Remember when SG-1 Season 9 came around? The joke was ScapeGate: SG-1 because two main characters of FarScape came on board.

    Remember when Atlantis Season 3 came around? The joke was Star-Files: Atlantis because a main character from X-Files came on board. Then over the next two year, other characters (minor and 1 main) came in and out of both series.

    Dr Carson Beckett asked to leave the show as well. So they kill him in the third season. But theyve already written atleast one script with him returning AND theyve said they will (if he wants to return) bring back the character, alive, in the second half of the season.

    Talks are in for both Jackson and Teal'c (has one cameo already announced) to be around once in awhile on Atlantis.

    I cannot form an opinion on Carter's permanent appearance on Atlantis until i see the final product.

    It was the same thing when O'Neill and Hammond left and Landry, Mitchell, and Vala came.

    What is happening to Weir's character? Reduced role in 4th season and taken off credits.
    Why did Tori decide to do this? Not yet released.
    Did Tapping contract force Higginson to leave? Speculative, controversial.
    Why is Carter coming onboard? To become the Atlantis Team Director.
    Will Carter stay beyond 1/2 a season? Unknown.
    What is happening to Dr. Beckett? His character is being killed off.
    Why is Paul McGillion leaving? Not quite clear.
    Why is Beckett returning? Unknown.
    Are these changes necessary? Dont know.
    Are these changes for better or worse? Cant say.
    Once a MARINE, Always a MARINE

    God Bless, Protect, and Speed,


    Robert Emmett Stephen Doyle IX


    Irish by ancestry, American by birth, but MARINE by the grace of God.
    Fortitudine Vincit, In Deo Speramus, Semper Fidelis

    SEMPERTOONS: http://www.sempertoons.com/
    SEMPERTOONS Store: www.cafepress.com/sempertoons

    Comment


      #3
      Originally posted by LoneReconEagle View Post

      People blame Amanda Tapping for Tori Higginson leaving, but Tori wanted out from the series. This not commonly known. They arrived at a medium of a reduced role for Tori. Amanda's role is for 10 episodes, half of the season.
      How do you know this?

      Comment


        #4
        we don't need two identitical threads going on

        those that are interested, head over to the atlantis s4 folder
        Where in the World is George Hammond?


        sigpic

        Comment

        Working...
        X