So, we have a Stargate vs. Star Wars discussion going, why not compare Stargate with Star Trek... I'm interested in finding out if people who think that Star Wars would get its butt whupped by Stargate will think Star Trek would be beaten even more soundly.
Star Trek DOES have a slower travel time, I will give Stargate the advantage there. The Federation and all races of reletively equal power level (Federation is in my opinion more powerful then the Romulans, Klingons and Cardasians despite the various advantages the others have, ie cloaking devices, etc) - and I think in terms of ship-to-ship combat Star Trek could compete with Stargate... heck, the Enterprise has met races like the Ori and the Ascended and survived an AWFUL lot of times
In terms of speed, yes, Stargate has the advantage - but I contend that if human beings can capture a Goa'uld ship and learn from the wreckage how to build ships that go just as fast, so could the Star Trek universe if they defeated a Ha'Tak, etc.
That begs another question, who would win: The Replicators or the Borg? I'd say the Replicators because they can eat the Borg lol
Star Trek DOES have a slower travel time, I will give Stargate the advantage there. The Federation and all races of reletively equal power level (Federation is in my opinion more powerful then the Romulans, Klingons and Cardasians despite the various advantages the others have, ie cloaking devices, etc) - and I think in terms of ship-to-ship combat Star Trek could compete with Stargate... heck, the Enterprise has met races like the Ori and the Ascended and survived an AWFUL lot of times
In terms of speed, yes, Stargate has the advantage - but I contend that if human beings can capture a Goa'uld ship and learn from the wreckage how to build ships that go just as fast, so could the Star Trek universe if they defeated a Ha'Tak, etc.
That begs another question, who would win: The Replicators or the Borg? I'd say the Replicators because they can eat the Borg lol
Comment